The Mermaid's Tale

Call Website Contact the business

The Mermaid's Tale We are a stylish boutique, filled with gifts, fashion & helpful, friendly service! You want to look great, feel great and make others feel the same.

Owner, Judy Recknagel, opened The Mermaid’s Tale in 1992 as a gift and antique shop. A few years later she phased out the antiques to bring her customers all the offerings of a woman’s boutique. She was excited to share her love of jewelry, handbags, clothing and so many more fabulous accessories with her customers! That’s where we come in. We have beautiful items in every price range. Whether it’s jewelry, handbags, clothing, shoes or an amazing gift, we have so many unique choices. Our staff is always on hand to give ideas and recommendations. We make shopping so fun and easy in our warm environment that people just can’t help coming back again and again!

🎃👻 Happy Halloween, Ghouls & Gals! 🧡🖤We're brewing up a little Halloween fun before we trade our witches' hats for Santa...
10/31/2026

🎃👻 Happy Halloween, Ghouls & Gals! 🧡🖤

We're brewing up a little Halloween fun before we trade our witches' hats for Santa hats! 🧙‍♀️🎅🎄

🕸️ TODAY, HALLOWEEN! 🕸️
We're OPEN 10 AM – 4 PM!

Stop in for a little retail trick-or-treating! 🛍️✨

🎄❤️ THEN... THE CHRISTMAS MAGIC BEGINS! ❤️🎄

Join us TOMORROW, Sunday, November 1st, from 12–5 PM for our 35th Annual Christmas Open House! 🎁

We'll be decking the halls, spreading holiday cheer, and kicking off the most wonderful time of the year with beautiful gifts, festive surprises, and so much more! ✨

🎃 A little spooky today, a whole lot of merry tomorrow! 🎄

We can't wait to celebrate with you at The Mermaid's Tale! 🧜‍♀️❤️

Happy Halloween! 🎃👻🧟🦇
10/31/2026

Happy Halloween! 🎃👻🧟🦇

HALLOWEEN DEAL OF THE DAY! Don't be scared to run out of candy, and don't miss out on having festive hot chocolate! The...
10/31/2026

HALLOWEEN DEAL OF THE DAY!

Don't be scared to run out of candy, and don't miss out on having festive hot chocolate!

These individually wrapped Spooky Ghost Natural Vanilla Flavor Marshmallows will save the day!

Regular price is $9.99. Today only - the price is $6.00!

First to call gets the deal. Call NOW to purchase! 440-988-7826.

Deal of the Day! You thought your Halloween costume was complete... UNTIL YOU SAW THESE SPIDER WEB TIGHTS!!! Size S/M a...
10/30/2026

Deal of the Day!

You thought your Halloween costume was complete... UNTIL YOU SAW THESE SPIDER WEB TIGHTS!!! Size S/M available now!

Regular price is $10. Today only - the price is $4!

First to call gets the deal. Call NOW to purchase! 440-988-7826.

🎄✨ It's beginning to look a lot like CHRISTMAS at The Mermaid's Tale! ✨🎄🎅🎁 35 YEARS OF HOLIDAY MAGIC! 🎁🎅The most wonderf...
10/29/2026

🎄✨ It's beginning to look a lot like CHRISTMAS at The Mermaid's Tale! ✨🎄

🎅🎁 35 YEARS OF HOLIDAY MAGIC! 🎁🎅

The most wonderful time of the year is almost here, and we're celebrating in a BIG way! ❤️💚

Grab your favorite shopping elves, put on your holiday spirit, and join us for our 35th Annual Christmas Open House! 🎄

📅 Sunday, November 1st
⏰ 12 PM – 5 PM

We've been busy making our list and checking it twice, and we've got some merry little surprises waiting for YOU! 🎁

✨ Brand-new goodies making their holiday debut!
🎄 Beautiful Old World Christmas ornaments!
🎁 Special gifts with purchase!
❤️ Meet some of the wonderful reps from your favorite brands!
✨ And plenty more Christmas magic!

Whether you're checking names off your Christmas list or treating yourself to a little holiday sparkle, we can't wait to celebrate with you!

🎅 35 years of making spirits bright, and it's all thanks to YOU! ❤️

📍 The Mermaid's Tale | 201 Church St., Amherst

🎄💕 Tag your shopping elves and make a date with us! Let the holiday magic begin! ✨🎁 See less

💛The Brighton Free Love Story Cosmetic Bag is ADORABLE! Available starting today through November 15th - while supplies...
10/29/2026

💛The Brighton Free Love Story Cosmetic Bag is ADORABLE! Available starting today through November 15th - while supplies last!💛

If you love this design in the picture you will love it even more in person!

🎅🏻🎄🎁Don't forget about our 35th Annual Christmas Open House this Sunday November 1 from 12pm-5pm, est.🎁🎄🎅🏻

Come see us today for a sneak peek of Christmas items and get this promotion while it's available - they will go very fast!

BOO! 👻 We're two days away from Halloween. Who's ready? 📷: instagram.com/mycharmstale
10/29/2026

BOO! 👻 We're two days away from Halloween. Who's ready?
📷: instagram.com/mycharmstale

It's time for TREAT Thursday! We bring you 5 great HALLOWEEN Deals of the Day to choose from. Buy 1 or 2 - or buy them ...
10/29/2026

It's time for TREAT Thursday!

We bring you 5 great HALLOWEEN Deals of the Day to choose from.

Buy 1 or 2 - or buy them all! These SPOOKY Cocktail Picks are PERFECT for any Halloween festivities!

Either way the rules are the same - first to call gets the item or items they want.

#1 - Two's Company Festive Orange Jack O'Lantern Cocktail Picks.
Regular price is $7.50. Today only - the price is $3.75!

#2 - Two's Company Spooky Eyeball Cocktail Picks.
Regular price is $7.50. Today only - the price is $3.75!

#3 - Two's Company Creepy Crawly Black Spider Cocktail Picks.
Regular price is $7.50. Today only - the price is $3.75!

#4 - Two's Company Playful Ghost Cocktail Picks.
Regular price is $7.50. Today only - the price is $3.75!

#5 - Two's Company Enchanting Witch Hat Cocktail Picks.
Regular price is $7.50. Today only - the price is $3.75!

First to call gets the deal on the item or items desired. Call NOW to purchase! 440-988-7826.

10/28/2026

It’s Time for Wacky Wednesday!

Address

201 Church Street
Amherst, OH
44001

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 5pm
Tuesday 10am - 5pm
Wednesday 10am - 5pm
Thursday 10am - 5pm
Friday 10am - 5pm
Saturday 10am - 4pm

Telephone

+14409887826

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Mermaid's Tale posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Mermaid's Tale:

Shortcuts

Share

Category

Nearby shops

Other Boutique Stores in Amherst

Show All