The Witch’s Pantry

The Witch’s Pantry Small-batch sourdough, preserves & treats.

Formerly That’s My Jam!, now The Witch’s Pantry—where everything is handcrafted with patience, a pinch of magic, and a little bit of mischief. 🌙🖤

✨ The ovens are on✨Friday afternoon + Saturday night are going to be the major baking days here at The Witch’s Pantry th...
09/17/2026

✨ The ovens are on✨

Friday afternoon + Saturday night are going to be the major baking days here at The Witch’s Pantry this week 🧙🏻‍♀️🍞

So if you’ve been thinking about placing an order, now’s the time! I’ll be filling this week’s orders while the ovens are already hot! Sourdough, Bewitched Buns, Hearthside sweets & all your favorites. 🖤

📩 Get those orders in ASAP so I can add you to this weekend’s bake!

As always, fermented with a little bit of mischief. ✨

Biscoff Broomsticks have entered the Bewitched Buns lineup! 🧹Soft cinnamon rolls filled with Biscoff cookie butter and B...
09/16/2026

Biscoff Broomsticks have entered the Bewitched Buns lineup! 🧹
Soft cinnamon rolls filled with Biscoff cookie butter and Biscoff cookie crumbles, topped with a Biscoff-infused vanilla glaze, warm cookie butter drizzle & crushed Biscoff cookies

Harvest Hex, but make it grilled cheese. 🌶️🧀✨Turns out a little cheddar jalapeño sourdough makes one wickedly good grill...
09/15/2026

Harvest Hex, but make it grilled cheese. 🌶️🧀✨
Turns out a little cheddar jalapeño sourdough makes one wickedly good grilled cheese.

The Pantry is back open for weekly orders! 🖤🔮After a little post-market recovery, I’m officially taking orders again for...
09/14/2026

The Pantry is back open for weekly orders! 🖤🔮

After a little post-market recovery, I’m officially taking orders again for your sourdough, sweets & Preserved Potions. 🥖✨

Take a peek at the menu and message me to place your order! 🖤

As always, fermented with a little bit of mischief.

09/13/2026

✨ SUNDAY PORCH PICKUP! ✨

Yesterday’s market was AMAZING, and I came home with just a few goodies still available from The Witch’s Pantry! 🖤🧙🏻‍♀️

🍞 Sourdough loaves $14 each or 2 for $25
• 3 Gilded Gourd
• 2 Brine & Brimstone

🍪 Hearthside Witch’s Sweets $5 each or 2 for $8
• 6 Maplewood Magic
• 8 Great Pumpkin Hex

🍰 Garden Witch’s Treats $3 a slice of 2 for $5
• 4 Carrot Cake Conjuring
• 2 Banished Banana Spell

🌀 Bewitched Buns
• Pumpkin Spice: 4 four-packs $15 each
• Pumpkin Spice: 3 individuals $5 each
• Caramel Apple: 1 four-pack $15 each
• Original: 1 individual $5 each

Porch pickup is available this morning OR this evening! 🏡✨

Message me to claim what you want + for pickup details. First come, first served! 🖤

🧙🏻‍♀️✨ THE WITCH’S PANTRY IS OPEN! ✨🧙🏻‍♀️We’re officially set up at Red Oak Brewery and ready for you! 🖤Come see us toda...
09/12/2026

🧙🏻‍♀️✨ THE WITCH’S PANTRY IS OPEN! ✨🧙🏻‍♀️

We’re officially set up at Red Oak Brewery and ready for you! 🖤

Come see us today from 1–7 PM for fresh sourdough, Bewitched Buns, sweet treats & potions while they last! 🍞✨

Come say hi and grab a treat!

Fermented with a little bit of mischief. 🧙🏻‍♀️

Market prep is officially in FULL swing 🧙🏻‍♀️🍞✨Cordelia has been working overtime over here, tubs of dough everywhere, l...
09/10/2026

Market prep is officially in FULL swing 🧙🏻‍♀️🍞✨

Cordelia has been working overtime over here, tubs of dough everywhere, loaves proofing, and my fridge is holding on for dear life 😂

Only 2 more days until the Red Oak Fall Festival! 🍂 Come see The Witch’s Pantry this Saturday from 1–7 PM
I cannot wait for you guys to see everything I’ve been working on! 🖤✨

Here’s a peek at what The Witch’s Pantry will be brewing at Red Oak this Saturday! 🧙🏼‍♀️🍞✨I’ve been baking, prepping, la...
09/09/2026

Here’s a peek at what The Witch’s Pantry will be brewing at Red Oak this Saturday! 🧙🏼‍♀️🍞✨

I’ve been baking, prepping, labeling, and getting ALL the little details ready, and I seriously cannot wait to set everything up and see you guys there! 🖤

📍 Red Oak Brewery
🗓 Saturday, September 12
⏰ 1–7 PM

See something you already know you’re coming for? 👀

I don’t think I’ll ever get tired of this part. 🥹✨ Taking the lids off mid-bake and seeing that oven spring gets me ever...
09/08/2026

I don’t think I’ll ever get tired of this part. 🥹✨ Taking the lids off mid-bake and seeing that oven spring gets me every single time. Cordelia really does know what she’s doing. 🖤🍞

Address

668 Struy St
Gibsonville, NC
27249

Telephone

+13362808191

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Witch’s Pantry posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Witch’s Pantry:

Shortcuts

Share