Who's on first? Sports cards and Collectibles

07/17/2026

07/12/2026

Gary McKenzie Buck Ellis

07/10/2026

07/10/2026

Another update: our air conditioning system is operational, maintaining a cool environment for our customers & Gary. Our new shop has commenced operations, and despite being a work in progress, we have been serving customers daily and are making steady progress. We are currently refining our inventory pricing and organization, with numerous products being readied for sale, which means new items will be available daily. Come get ya some! Gary McKenzie Buck Ellis

11/13/2025

I'm encouraged by the progress our community is making in addressing the stolen cards, with reports of sightings in Huntington and Ashland, and a second card recovered through a separate investigation. Our card community's collaboration and diligence are making a real difference.

11/10/2025

UPDATE on this morning’s episode of to catch a thief. With the help of the card community we have a vehicle description & plate # and picture of one of the perpetrators. Keep on the lookout and thanks to everyone who has liked and shared the post across many platforms.

11/10/2025

Early this morning we received a call from HPD that our shop had been broken into. We are working with them on an inventory list of the stolen items. There was a large amount of unopened product taken as well as some very highly identifiable cars including several PSA and SGC graded cards. Keep an eye out for deals to good to be true and reach out in PM if you have any questions or information regarding the stolen items.

09/09/2025

Who's On First? is thrilled to announce that we have secured a larger space located at the corner of US Route 60 and West P Ridge Road in Huntington. This expanded location will enable us to provide a wider range of offerings and enhance our customer service. We are eager to prepare this new space and anticipate opening before January 1, 2026. We would like to thank our loyal customers for their support at our First Street location over the past nine years. We look forward to seeing you at our new store and welcoming new customers to our expanded space.

09/01/2025

We are thrilled to celebrate nine years of serving the sports card collectors community at our Huntington store. Our deepest appreciation is extended to our past, present, and future customers for their steadfast support and loyalty. As we begin our tenth year, our objective is to identify opportunities to improve our service offerings and provide a unique experience for hobbyists spanning all ages. Look forward to an exciting announcement in the coming weeks. Sincerely, Buck & Gary