11/09/2026
ON THIS DAY in 2006 - 20 years ago exactly - Brooklyn indie rock outfit TV On The Radio released their second album 'Return To Cookie Mountain' on Touch and Go/Interscope. Since their debut 'Desperate Youth, Blood Thirsty Babes' (2004) the band's line-up had been bolstered by the addition of keyboardist Gerard Smith - drafted into the lineup by frontman Tunde Adebimpe - and the album was recorded at Stay Gold Studio and Head Gear Studio (both located in Brooklyn) with guitarist David Sitek producing. The album featured some prominent guest vocalists - including David Bowie, an avowed fan of their debut, who sang on 'Province', as well as Blonde Redhead's Kazu Makino who sang on 'Hours' - and it housed two strong singles in 'Wolf Like Me' and the aforementioned 'Province'. Critics loved the record from the get-go, with AllMusic's 5-star review reckoning, "As passionate as ever, but with a little more polish, TV on the Radio give their unapologetically ambitious sound room to breathe with a lush, expansive production on 'Return to Cookie Mountain'. The sonic depth throughout the album is a sharp contrast with the density of their first full-length, 'Desperate Youth, Blood Thirsty Babes', which was so jam-packed with sounds and ideas that it was nearly suffocated by them... the most complete representation of the hopes, joys, and fears within TV on the Radio's music" and Rolling Stone's 4 1/2 star review stating, "Evoking 'Fear of Music' Talking Heads, 'Station to Station' David Bowie and 'Sign ‘O’ the Times' Prince, the resulting disc might be the most oddly beautiful, psychedelic and ambitious of the year. (If you don’t own a good set of headphones, get one)". The album rose to #41 in the US, #50 in Australia and #90 in the UK but featured prominently in many 'end of year' lists, named the album of the year by Spin for 2006, leading to the band's appearance on the magazine's cover, was well as being ranked second on Pitchfork's list of Top 50 Albums of 2006 (Rolling Stone, Slant Magazine, and Stylus Magazine each named the album as the fourth best of 2006). The album has stood the test of time wonderfully and remains critically beloved, with a Stereogum retrospective for the album's 10th anniversary arguing, "So rather than facing down a sophomore slump, TVOTR were still in search of their defining statement as LP2 approached. With the preposterously titled 'Return To Cookie Mountain, they found it big time. Yes, the Super Mario World-repping album includes 'Wolf Like Me', their signature song and one of the greatest singles in rock history. But just as importantly, it's a thrill from start to finish. This was the album that established once and for all that TV On The Radio were more than just a great idea for a band; they were a great band, period".