04/08/2026
I’ve been getting quite a few questions about how to make an Amish Toothbrush Knot Rag Rug, so I’m going to pin this post to the top of my page to make things easier for everyone!
This way, you won’t have to scroll through the page looking for answers. I’ll continue to update this post over time by adding new questions and answers as they come in 😊
Q: Why is it called an Amish Toothbrush Knot rug?
A: Amish rag rugs are made by knotting strips of fabric together using a series of stitches similar to a blanket stitch in sewing. Unlike traditional rugs, these are not woven on a loom. Instead, they’re built starting from the center and worked outward, which means you can make them any size you like!
They’re also known as toothbrush rugs because, years ago, the tools used to make them were often handmade from old toothbrush handles. A slot would be carved into the end of the handle so fabric strips could be fed through—creating a simple but effective needle.
-
Q: How wide should I cut my fabric strips?
A: The width of your fabric strips depends on the type of fabric you’re using. Thinner fabrics should be cut wider, while thicker fabrics can be cut a bit narrower.
For cotton, I usually cut my strips around 3–4 inches wide, as wider strips tend to hold up better over time. Some tutorials suggest cutting them at 2½ inches, but I find that slightly wider strips help reduce wear and tear.
Once you get the hang of it, you’ll find the width that works best for you and your style!
-
Q: I’m getting gaps as I make my knots—what am I doing wrong?
A: When you’re first starting your rug, it’s normal to notice some gaps appearing. Don’t hesitate to add two or even three knots into one loop to help fill those spaces and keep your rug nice and tight.
If you’ve already moved past an area and notice gaps later, don’t worry—you can always go back and sew it together to make the knots more consistent with the rest of the rug.
It gets easier as you go, and your tension will become more even with practice!
-
Q: My rug is starting to bow—why is this happening?
A: As you make your rug, it’s very important to keep it flat while you work. Pulling too tightly on the runner will can cause the rug to curl or bowl-shaped. Try to keep your knots even and slightly loose. As the rug gets bigger, the knots will naturally tighten on their own. Put the runner to the side and don't pull on it. Runner is just to be guided along and to be the spine of the rug.
Q: The runner in the kits is made from white sheets—does it have to be white?
A: Some of you may notice that I use white sheets rolled into a ball for the runner (also known as the spine of the rug). No, it definitely doesn’t have to be white! I use white simply because a friend generously donated sheets from her B&B. Since the runner isn’t visible in the finished rug, you can use any color you like.
-
✨ Thinking of giving it a try?
My Amish Toothbrush Knot starter kits include everything you need to make your own small rug or trivet—perfect for beginners or as a cozy little project. Feel free to message me anytime if you have questions or want to get started!
