03/05/2024
Bugs, bags, buckets and belly’s or “ Wha cha usin ?”
I posted this pic a couple years ago.
It’s the stomach contents (no fish were hurt during the filming) of a single feeding 20’ Rainbow.
BWO’s, Caddis nymph, Water Boatmen, Chironomids, various other beetles and even a Stonefly. ( I have a collection of 100 + bags, little buckets and Tim Horton’s cups in my freezer with these critters in them…yeah…I’m single so it’s MY Freezer and I can fill it with what I want.)
Sept.15,2020. A 20" Rainbow ate a CDC Caddis dry variation during a midge/BWO hatch.
Yes – I had BWO’s, Caddis nymphs, Water Boatmen, Chironomids, various other beetles and even a Stoneflies with me.
The rule for Bow River rising fish is not complex…when fish are eating Caddis – fish a Caddis. When they are (I hate fishing cliché’s) “on” BWO’s – I fish a ….Caddis. If I find fish eating Trico’s – I fish a Caddis. ( seeing a pattern here ? ) .
If there isn’t anything - “coming off” (stupid cliche phrases) …I search with a Caddis.
Last fall while guiding. I took a client into some water I really like …and hate. The fish are super tough, getting close enough to cast - 90%+ of the time makes them aware that we are there. ( I think this water - is little silly full with fish, but they aren’t all always rising. I’m probably pushing unseen fish up, that spook and during the process, alert the rising fish. Kerry, Dave, Rob, Mike M. and Jim – you know what I’m talking about.)
Extremely slowly, I walked the boat up, my angler in the bow, me pulling the boat with him towards the fish. He was NOT wading with me. I’m 100 % certain that having him walk with me would have spooked these. We were chasing one fish. It’s a Rainbow and BIG. ( 24"+ class – thick and firm - like steelhead big.)
I did some of that "secret guide stuff", us "secret guides" do to get his set-up just right, you know the kinda stuff you don't read about.
The client and I were talking strategy, spotting, tracking this fish and then he asks –“What is it eating ?”
I’d tied on my Bow River Caddis. It’s a fly I developed, has some very special qualities like – floats high, lands super soft, you can see it REALLY easily and when a fish eats it – they feel nothing until it’s deep in their kisser. To me, a pretty special little bug.
I’d once had one of these Caddis eaten by a sighted fish…I said to that client – Brady, “ Brady – set the hook.”
Brady, having fished with me for years by then did exactly what every guide wants and said “ No Glenn. That wasn’t me.”
My reply, “ Yes Brady, that was you !”
I’d seen the fish eat the fly, then drop back down in the water column, slowly the leader developed a bend as the fish after 15 seconds felt something was wrong, line tension I think, and started to swim downstream…
Again he said “ Nope – Not me…”
My reply was very un-Glenn Guide like and I won’t insert it here – I’m sure you can guess something similar though …but he did lift the rod.
The line went tight …followed by the stuff you have all seen before…Brady’s fish ate that Caddis, I’m certain never felt the material or hook, never shook it's head or attempted to spit the fly out.
Brady did not get a guide “I told you so” with me sauntering back to the boat with a wet smells like fish net.
Instead - with great understanding and professionally : “ Brady next time a guide asks you to set the hook, just trust us and set it.”
So when this client asked what is it eating ? I told him.
“ Trico’s – they’re eating fallen Tric’s” (Pronounced “ Tryk” like a kids Tricycle) . This was a spinner fall and the fish were eating Tric’s.
He looked down at the fly he was holding to ask me with a small hint of disapproval : “ What fly is this ?”
“ It's a Such n' Such Caddis” ….then it happened - again.
My client told me that he was NOT going to do something I asked.
No way was HE going to cast a CADDIS to a fish, if the fish was CLEARLY eating TRICO's.
(Picture now - a petite but powerful nuclear explosion occurring in my head.)
I went into my spiel about “trusting me”, fishing to these fish before, blah blah blah.
What I should have said would have been very frank – “ If I know enough to know - exactly - when we need to be here, - exactly - what to look for and I’m able to get you from 100’ to 30’ away from the fish - so you can cover it ? Do you REALLY think I’m going to let you cast a fly it won’t eat?”
I appreciate him though – despite it feeling a little odd to him to cast a Caddis to a Trico fish – he did. Better yet, from his casting - I could see that he clearly understood and was as committed to the process as I.
1st cast right 6” ‘s and a little short, the next cast left but long enough, the fish was moving side to side looking for food – the 3rd cast – Absolutely Fu…umm…Absolutely Fishing Perfect !
This ..ummm… is wa**er an appropriate word to describe a fish ? This wa**er, swam downstream right at us, turned cut to deep water, across and under aquatic grass…and jumped – with a counter clockwise spin…beside us - then it hit the slowmo button on the remote - …and gave us the “fin”-ger as the hook came out. Wa**er!
Assumptions I've made were confirmed and lessons learned :
#1 – we actually don’t KNOW what fish see when they look at a fly from below. I have my theories and assumptions. But we don’t KNOW know. Did it think it was a Trico? A Caddis ? Or just food…I dunno?!
#2 – Fly fishermen often think its ALLLL about the fly. There’s some crazy stuff being tied out there. Perfect imitations, sexy bright colors like the Lamborghini color palate, “lips/legs and butt holes” a friend used to say. My point being that we- fly fishers- often get tunnel vision, maybe the magazines and articles over sell “Matching the Hatch”.
# 3 - I often spend a day, trying to introduce an Alberta or Western angling habits to someone who has – New York, Pennsylvania, Steelhead, Cutthroat or Saltwater skills. A Montana Guide would likely watch these fishers on his water for a few minutes and drawl out deftly “ You Ain’t from round ha’h is ya?” All fly fisher people develop a naturally organic skills set that suits their home waters. McLennan once told me : “ Fish lots of different places and you will learn different ways to catch trout”.
I know these Bow River fish, they have been my teachers for 35 yrs now, only 5 minutes away. For those of us that live in Calgary – that’s kind of special. The Red Deer contingent – you have all kinds of creeks with magnificent fish just half an hour away and some closer (NO - I will not drop names/locations). My clients from Toronto, Texas, LA – they are 4-5 hours or a whole day's drive away from quality fishing. Alberta water is pretty special, close and allows us all to hone skills and have some fun – we need to keep protecting it. Not everyone is so lucky.
That fish ate that fly because we did everything right – even if it wasn’t a Trico. It also ate the same fly again a few days later. That time it swam downstream, under the grass, jumped and – heavy guide guy sigh here - pulled loose again. The hatches ended, water changed - I looked for it but didn't see it again.
So, on the topic of flies and fly selection…yeah it matters. But to the trout, so do the other dozen or so types “BUGS” that drifted by that day, we never saw and ended up in my little bucket/bag or a trout belly.
It’s May.2 – we are in it now. Have fun out there and maybe if you have a few minutes – get involved with the protection societies that are looking out for our trout water.