Bethany Sports Cards Plus

Bethany Sports Cards Plus A locally owned sports cards and memorabilia store nestled in the heart of Bethany Beach, Delaware!

At Bethany Sports Cards Plus, we are a locally owned sports cards and memorabilia store nestled in the heart of Bethany Beach, Delaware. We specialize in both vintage and modern collectibles, focusing on sports cards, sealed wax boxes, Pokémon cards, autographed items, and more for sports fans of all ages. With our knowledgeable, friendly team who truly love what we do, you’ll find personalized se

rvice, expert guidance, and a welcoming atmosphere that makes every visit memorable. Whether you’re an avid collector or just looking for a unique gift, we’re a must-stop destination in Bethany Beach.

📢 New Hours Starting Tuesday, September 8thMon – Thu: 9 AM – 5 PM Fri – Sat: 9 AM – 7 PM Sun: 9 AM – 1 PMCome see us at ...
09/06/2026

📢 New Hours Starting Tuesday, September 8th

Mon – Thu: 9 AM – 5 PM
Fri – Sat: 9 AM – 7 PM
Sun: 9 AM – 1 PM

Come see us at Bethany Sports Cards Plus! 🏆📇

🔥 RIP IT. HIT IT. KEEP IT OR TRADE IT BACK. 🔥ML Hits Baseball Series 1 is here — and ripping in store gives you another ...
09/04/2026

🔥 RIP IT. HIT IT. KEEP IT OR TRADE IT BACK. 🔥

ML Hits Baseball Series 1 is here — and ripping in store gives you another option after the chase.

Open your pack at Bethany Sports Cards Plus and receive a 90% store-credit buyback offer based on current Card Ladder value.

⚾ PSA-graded cards
💵 $80 minimum floor
🚀 $600+ ceiling
🔁 90% in-store buyback

Autos, Kabooms, vintage legends, rookies and more are all in the mix.

Available exclusively at Bethany Sports Cards Plus.

⚾ VINTAGE LEGENDS. MODERN STARS. ONE SERIES. ⚾ML Hits Baseball Series 1 brings together generations of the hobby.Think M...
08/28/2026

⚾ VINTAGE LEGENDS. MODERN STARS. ONE SERIES. ⚾

ML Hits Baseball Series 1 brings together generations of the hobby.

Think Mickey Mantle and Ken Griffey Jr. alongside Bobby Witt Jr., Yordan Alvarez, Nick Kurtz and more — with autos, rookies, inserts and serious chase cards throughout the series.

🔥 $80 Floor
🔥 $600+ Ceiling
🔥 90% buyback for store credit when ripped in store
🔥 Card Ladder value used as comp

Legendary past. Modern power.

Exclusively at Bethany Sports Cards Plus.

2026 Topps Chrome Black Basketball is here at Bethany Sports Cards Plus.This release brings the full Chrome Black lineup...
08/27/2026

2026 Topps Chrome Black Basketball is here at Bethany Sports Cards Plus.

This release brings the full Chrome Black lineup to the hardwood — Refractors, on-card rookie and veteran autographs, and short-printed parallels, with 1/1 Superfractors at the top of the chase.

Boxes available now. Stop by to grab yours.

📍 Bethany Sports Cards Plus

—

2026 Topps Flagship Football arrives August 21 at Bethany Sports Cards Plus.The season kicks off with Topps’ flagship re...
08/21/2026

2026 Topps Flagship Football arrives August 21 at Bethany Sports Cards Plus.

The season kicks off with Topps’ flagship release — rookie cards, on-card autographs, relic cards, and exclusive Foilboard parallels to chase, all in the classic Flagship design collectors know.

Boxes available the day of release. Stop by to grab yours.

📍 Bethany Sports Cards Plus

—

THE FLOOR. THE CEILING. THE CHASE. ⚾🔥Introducing ML Hits Baseball Series 1.Every pack delivers a PSA-graded baseball car...
08/21/2026

THE FLOOR. THE CEILING. THE CHASE. ⚾🔥

Introducing ML Hits Baseball Series 1.

Every pack delivers a PSA-graded baseball card with an $80 minimum floor and potential hits reaching $600+.

And if you rip it in store, the chase doesn’t have to end with the card you pull:

🔁 90% store-credit buyback
📊 Based on current Card Ladder value

From Babe Ruth and Mickey Mantle to Kabooms, autographs, rookies and modern stars — Baseball Series 1 covers the hobby from past to present.

Available exclusively at Bethany Sports Cards Plus.

THE FLOOR. THE CEILING. THE CHASE.ML Hits Pokémon Series 1 is officially here.Every pack contains a PSA-graded Pokémon c...
08/21/2026

THE FLOOR. THE CEILING. THE CHASE.

ML Hits Pokémon Series 1 is officially here.

Every pack contains a PSA-graded Pokémon card, with an $80 minimum floor and possible hits valued at $600 or more.

Rip it in store and decide what comes next:

Keep your hit—or take a 90% store-credit buyback offer based on current Card Ladder value.

Available exclusively at Bethany Sports Cards Plus.

⚡ VINTAGE HITS. MODERN CHASES. ONE SERIES. ⚡ML Hits Pokémon Series 1 brings together cards from across the hobby—from vi...
08/14/2026

⚡ VINTAGE HITS. MODERN CHASES. ONE SERIES. ⚡

ML Hits Pokémon Series 1 brings together cards from across the hobby—from vintage favorites to modern alternate arts, illustration rares and secret rares.

Every pack includes a PSA-graded Pokémon card with:

💵 $80 Floor
🚀 $600+ Ceiling
🔄 90% buyback for store credit when ripped in store
📈 Card Ladder value used as the comp

Which possible case hit are you chasing?

Available exclusively at Bethany Sports Cards Plus.

Topps Museum UEFA Club Competitions 2025/26 is here at Bethany Sports Cards Plus.Topps Museum Collection brings its prem...
08/13/2026

Topps Museum UEFA Club Competitions 2025/26 is here at Bethany Sports Cards Plus.

Topps Museum Collection brings its premium, gallery-style design to the 2025/26 UEFA Champions, Europa, and Conference League season — framed wood-and-marble cards, on-card autographs, and museum-worthy relics, with numbered Showpiece Signatures and Roll of Honor legends among the chase.

Boxes available now. Stop by to grab yours.

📍 Bethany Sports Cards Plus

—

2026 Topps Pristine Baseball is here at Bethany Sports Cards Plus.This release brings the signature Pristine shine to th...
08/12/2026

2026 Topps Pristine Baseball is here at Bethany Sports Cards Plus.

This release brings the signature Pristine shine to the diamond — encased autographs, player-worn relics, and refractor parallels, with rookie autos and 1/1s at the top of the chase.

Boxes available now. Stop by to grab yours.

📍 Bethany Sports Cards Plus

—

Address

123 Garfield Pkwy Unit 7
Bethany Beach, DE
19930

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 4pm
Tuesday 10am - 4pm
Wednesday 10am - 4pm
Thursday 10am - 4pm
Friday 10am - 5pm
Saturday 10am - 5pm
Sunday 10am - 5pm

Telephone

+13025376330

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Bethany Sports Cards Plus posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Bethany Sports Cards Plus:

Shortcuts

Share

Category