06/15/2026
- Yesteryear, by Caro Claire Burke
Tradwife influencer Natalie Mills seems to have it all. She shows off her successful organic farm, cheerful children, home-cooked recipes and redblooded provider of a husband to millions on social media, proving that the conservative American dream can be a reality.
Of course, real life is very different. The husband is a redpill b**b, the children neglected, and the real work done by hired hands, nannies, and a pink-haired liberal producer. When Natalie suddenly wakes up in 1855 and has to be a tradwife for real, things get even more complicated.
This book has been riding high on the wave of a very timely concept and Anne Hathaway-helmed film option. It's sparked some nteresting discussion, and has a particularly nasty plot twist meant to drive it's Aesop home hard.
But I can't shake the feeling that ultimately this book hates women just as much as the people it's satirizing.
Every woman in this book is miserable, whether liberal or conservative. Every man is rich, dumb and unpunished. No one is given the courtesy of a viewpoint specific enough to feel truly meaningful. Natalie is a generic caricature of a conservative rural white lady from an unspecified but tacitly ridiculous religion. (Geographically she should be Mormon but seems evangelical? But also has no church, just sourdough and platitudes.)
By the time we get to the twist (spoiler alert: it's a psychotic episode, no real time travel) Natalie is more punching bag than person. She exists for people to feel superior to, rather than as a reflection of the attitudes and existence of conservative white women. She's a revenge fantasy, and a mean-spirited one, too.
Also, it goes without saying, but this is *super* white. I hoped to gain some insight on what's happening in America's cultural bubbles, both right and left. Instead, I got a 400-page treatise on self-righteous mean-girlism.(Maybe that IS what's happening?) Never been so glad to be Black and weird and womanist in my life.
Also, you absolutely cannot knit with sewing needles and that part almost got the book returned.
Names in the Burn Book for Yesteryear.
ID and tags in comments.