Cape May Peanut Butter Co.

Cape May Peanut Butter Co. Our famous housemade nut butters, peanut butter treats, & more in America’s original seaside resort! Not in Cape May? We ship! 🥜🇺🇸
(411)

June 21st is National Cookie Dough Day! 🍪 Our “eat it, don’t bake it” edible Peanut Butter Cookie Dough allows you to en...
06/19/2026

June 21st is National Cookie Dough Day! 🍪 Our “eat it, don’t bake it” edible Peanut Butter Cookie Dough allows you to enjoy spoonfuls of our delicious peanut butter cookie dough straight from the jar. No waiting for baking required!

June 18th is National Picnic Day! Our selection of grab-and-go peanut butter sandwiches is perfect for a picnic in Cape ...
06/18/2026

June 18th is National Picnic Day! Our selection of grab-and-go peanut butter sandwiches is perfect for a picnic in Cape May! Stop by the shop and grab one to take to the beach, the park, or simply your backyard, and enjoy the great outdoors AND the taste of our famous peanut butters.

Stop by the shop this Father’s Day Weekend and treat dad to one of our famous peanut butter treats! Whether it be a pean...
06/17/2026

Stop by the shop this Father’s Day Weekend and treat dad to one of our famous peanut butter treats! Whether it be a peanut butter baked good from our bakery case or a jar of our Wingnutz peanuts, he deserves it!

June 12th is National Peanut Butter Cookie Day! Indulge in a taste of pure bliss with our decadent freshly baked peanut ...
06/12/2026

June 12th is National Peanut Butter Cookie Day! Indulge in a taste of pure bliss with our decadent freshly baked peanut butter cookies from our bakery case. 🥜🍪✨ Made with love and packed with peanut buttery goodness, every bite is a little piece of heaven!

06/11/2026

June’s Milkshake of the Month is a butterscotch dream 🤤🥤

We start with a creamy vanilla base and swirl in our rich, buttery Cape May Peanut Butter Co. Butter Scotch peanut butter, then top it with fluffy whipped cream, a generous drizzle of butterscotch sauce, and plenty of our snickerdoodle cookie crumbles for that perfect cinnamon-sugar finish.

It’s smooth, sweet, a little salty, and packed with that deep, buttery butterscotch flavor in every sip… this one’s calling your name.

06/10/2026

Smashwich season is here 🍦🔥

June is National Mango Month! 🥭 Made with sweet tropical mango fruit, Mrs. Miller's Homemade Mango Jam is a tasty tropic...
06/05/2026

June is National Mango Month! 🥭 Made with sweet tropical mango fruit, Mrs. Miller's Homemade Mango Jam is a tasty tropical jam.

The mango fruit is known as the king of fruits and originates in Southeast Asia. It is known for its sweet luscious taste and nutritional qualities. Mangoes are rich in vitamins and antioxidants. Most importantly though, they result in a delicious jam that will give you a wonderful spread on your toast without requiring a journey to Southeast Asia to harvest them.

Find it in the shop or online at capeislandfoods.com/product/mango-jam/BL7HZ2YB5IR4KWF4IPECCCKX.

June is National Lemon Month! The house-made Lemon & Coconut Italian Biscotti that we carry from our sister shop Cape Ma...
06/03/2026

June is National Lemon Month! The house-made Lemon & Coconut Italian Biscotti that we carry from our sister shop Cape May Olive Oil Co. is perfect with coffee, fine teas, red wines, or as a late night snack. Find it here in the shop or online at capeislandfoods.com/product/lemon-coconut-italian-biscotti/MGHSVLLOGBAKMFAD4GEKKD6L.

Summer is on our doorstep, and with it comes warmer temperatures that make shipping our delicious chocolate products and...
06/01/2026

Summer is on our doorstep, and with it comes warmer temperatures that make shipping our delicious chocolate products and our Peanut Butter Cookie Dough a bit tricky. We want to ensure you receive these treats in the best condition, which means we’ll be pausing online sales of these products starting June 5th. But don’t worry—they’ll be back for online orders in the fall!

If you can’t visit our shop in Cape May in person this summer, now is the perfect time to stock up on your favorite goodies. This is your last chance to have our mouth-watering chocolate peanut butter treats and our cookie dough shipped directly to your door until the cooler weather returns.

Place your order before June 5th to ensure you have all the chocolatey goodness you need for the summer months ahead at capeislandfoods.com/shop/treats/MAPYWSLK6MOX73PDAYFZCY5F.

Cape May Peanut Butter Co. is excited to celebrate the three major anniversaries being recognized in Cape May this year:...
05/30/2026

Cape May Peanut Butter Co. is excited to celebrate the three major anniversaries being recognized in Cape May this year: 175 years of the City of Cape May, 50 years as a National Historic Landmark, and 250 years of the United States of America! 🇺🇸

To honor these incredible milestones, Cape May City has launched a unified, citywide marketing and storytelling website that will highlight events in real time and serve as the hub for this year-long celebration.

Check it out at capemayfirstandonly.com!

Use it to plan your Cape May adventures this year—and don’t forget to make a stop at Cape May Peanut Butter Co. part of the experience! 🥜

Address

516 Carpenters Lane
Cape May, NJ
08204

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 9pm
Tuesday 10am - 9pm
Wednesday 10am - 9pm
Thursday 10am - 9pm
Friday 10am - 9pm
Saturday 10am - 9pm
Sunday 10am - 9pm

Telephone

+16098984444

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Cape May Peanut Butter Co. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Cape May Peanut Butter Co.:

Shortcuts

Share

Category