08/05/2026
Another incredible piece of comic book history is back from CGC!
Amazing Spider-Man #1 (1963) 🕷️
From the very beginning, we set realistic expectations with our client based on a thorough inspection of the book.
Our prediction:
✅ 1.5 was the most likely outcome.
✅ 1.8 was possible if the page quality held up.
🤞 2.0 would have been a pleasant surprise.
The biggest limiting factor was the brittle page quality. While the cover presented well for the grade, the interior ultimately kept the book where we expected it to land.
Final Grade: CGC 1.5 (Cream to Off-White Pages)
Needless to say, we’re thrilled with the result—and more importantly, so is our client.
One of the biggest values we provide isn’t just pressing and submissions. It’s taking the time to carefully evaluate each book, explain what affects the grade, and set honest expectations before it ever leaves your hands. There are no guarantees in grading, but experience and transparency go a long way.
Thank you to our client for trusting us with such an iconic piece of Marvel history. It’s always an honor to handle books that helped shape the hobby we all love.
Thinking about submitting your comics or cards? We’d be happy to evaluate them and help you decide whether grading makes sense before you spend the money.