With Sugar Added

With Sugar Added Welcome to my cottage bakery! I am located in Edgerton, but can arrange for pick up in Bryan as well. Any questions or to place an order, please send a message!

I love baking gourmet cookies, cookie cakes, brownies and other yummy treats for you!

09/26/2026
😋 My latest recipe did not disappoint! I present “Cinnamon Swirl Banana Cake” 🍌 One of my taste testers said it’s like b...
09/17/2026

😋 My latest recipe did not disappoint! I present “Cinnamon Swirl Banana Cake” 🍌 One of my taste testers said it’s like banana bread cinnamon roll meets Cinnamon Toast Crunch! Will have these available on October 3rd at the Fall Festival in Edgerton.

🍓Baking is my therapy 🧁 Ok, so it’s more the taste testing 😂🤣Next up is Banana Toffee Caramel Cake Jars and Biscoff Cake...
09/16/2026

🍓Baking is my therapy 🧁 Ok, so it’s more the taste testing 😂🤣

Next up is Banana Toffee Caramel Cake Jars and Biscoff Cake Jars!

🍪Sharing some of the bakes I’ve been working on for the upcoming Fall Fest on October 3rd in Edgerton. I will have 12 va...
09/05/2026

🍪Sharing some of the bakes I’ve been working on for the upcoming Fall Fest on October 3rd in Edgerton. I will have 12 varieties of cookies, sweet breads like pumpkin, banana, zucchini, cake in jars(new for me!)and oatmeal cream pies.

❤️ Father’s Day Sale! 💙I am excited to offer an upgraded version of my Fluffy Nutter Cookies, now featuring the new Rees...
06/19/2026

❤️ Father’s Day Sale! 💙

I am excited to offer an upgraded version of my Fluffy Nutter Cookies, now featuring the new Reese's Marshmallow Cup.

Also available is our Loaded Peanut Buttter Cookies filled with Reese’s Pieces, Peanut Butter Chips & Mini PB Cups.

$3 per cookie. To place an order, please message me and arrange for pickup.

My newest cookie- Blue Monster CookieA fun twist on my chocolate chip cookies-with Oreos, Chips Ahoy, white chocolate ch...
06/02/2026

My newest cookie- Blue Monster Cookie

A fun twist on my chocolate chip cookies-with Oreos, Chips Ahoy, white chocolate chips. Perfect for your little cookie lovers!

🍪 S’mores Cookies 🍪
05/31/2026

🍪 S’mores Cookies 🍪

I have just 6 Deep Dish Cookies left! Perfect gift for your Valentine!💘$18
02/14/2026

I have just 6 Deep Dish Cookies left! Perfect gift for your Valentine!💘
$18

🩷❤️🩷 What better way to spend an afternoon when snowed in 😋
01/25/2026

🩷❤️🩷 What better way to spend an afternoon when snowed in 😋

🩷❤️🩷 Perfect treat for Valentine's Day (Feb 14th) or Galentine's Day (Feb 13th)! Chocolate Chip M&M’s Deep Dish Cookies....
01/22/2026

🩷❤️🩷 Perfect treat for Valentine's Day (Feb 14th) or Galentine's Day (Feb 13th)! Chocolate Chip M&M’s Deep Dish Cookies.
🩷1/2 dozen $18
❤️1 dozen $30
Pick up in Edgerton or Bryan
Please message me to order!

Address

Private
Edgerton, OH
43517

Telephone

+14197992031

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when With Sugar Added posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to With Sugar Added:

Shortcuts

Share

Category