More Pennies From Heaven

09/18/2026

09/16/2026

Next month, we’re giving the store a little refresh! We wanted to give our customers a heads up that we will be closed October 8-12, with a grand reopening on Oct 13!

Don’t worry, it’s still going to be the same More Pennies you know and love: good finds, low prices, and friendly faces. ❤️ Just with a fresh new look!

We’ll be sharing more reminders and updates about the grand reopening as we get closer, so keep an eye out!

09/04/2026

Fall and Halloween are here in the store! Costumes for $1, and freshly stocked fall decor and household items. Come on in!

09/01/2026

Mugs are buy one get one all week long! Who doesn’t love a bogo!? Great excuse to pour yourself a cup of tea and cozy up this week!

08/25/2026

Last minute back to school shopping? Stop by More Pennies From Heaven before you look anywhere else! You might find just what you’re looking for, and you’ll save big too!!

08/19/2026

What’s New Wednesday - come check our new displays! We’ve moved some racks and tables around and made some extra fun changes in the store!

08/13/2026

Come see what’s new in store!! Open today until 6, Friday and Saturday until 4. 🤩

07/31/2026

🌟 FLASH FRIDAY SALE! 🌟

Happy Friday! Today only, enjoy 20% OFF all women’s apparel at More Pennies From Heaven Thrift Store!

📍 1806 Cole Street. Come shop today! We can’t wait to see you!

07/29/2026

We are looking for volunteers who want to learn to be a cashier! You must be 18 or over. Great opportunity to serve with us, and gain some retail experience if you have the time!

07/28/2026

📣 Calling all scrapbookers, card makers, and paper craft lovers! ✂️📖💕

You are going to want to stop by More Pennies From Heaven! Steph, our Assistant Store Manager, generously donated an incredible collection of scrapbooking and paper crafting supplies, and they’re out on the sales floor NOW.

Whether you’re working on memory books, handmade cards, journals, or your next creative project, there are plenty of treasures waiting to be discovered.

PLUS it’s 20% off for seniors, veterans, and educators every Tuesday!