Gray Gauntlet Games

05/07/2026

Hey all! We have the upcoming Magic the Gathering: Marvel Super Heroes available to preorder in store. All prices are at MSRP for preorders through prerelease day!
Collector Box - 479.88
Collector Commander Case - 639.96
Play Booster Box - 172.49
Draft Night - 119.00
Jumpstart Booster Box - 138.71
Bundle - 69.99
Beginner Box - 34.99
Scene Box Set of 2 - 83.98

We also have a special Bundle that includes 1 collector booster box, 1 play booster box, 1 Set of all 4 commanders and 1 Bundle for 950.99. Save over 70 off MSRP!

05/06/2026

Looking for a open, welcoming and friendly place to hang out and play MTG Commander, Draft, Sealed or Prerelease?

If you are brand new to the game, wanting to learn or an experienced veteran, everyone has a seat at our table.

Stop by Gray Gauntlet Games, we run weekly events for Magic the Gathering.
Check out our Calendar! https://graygauntletgames.com/pages/events

We have tons of cards in stock, place orders online for in store pickup or browse our selection in store.
Preorders available at MSRP for upcoming MTG Sets

04/21/2026

We are looking to buy any and all Magic the Gathering Bulk. Must be in good condition. Drop off or ship in. Submit your bulk cards here! https://graygauntletgames.com/pages/mtg-bulk-submission?srsltid=AfmBOorXP08q6EEjeQWZ1JAw559xdxIj4m8qKinACEqvPbY-JS78xyqu

04/18/2026

Hey all! Strixhaven is here!

04/17/2026

Secrets of Strixhaven Collector Booster Pack Opening by Gray Gauntlet Games. We also have a new channel on Youtube were we will post all our pack opening videos. We will have a new TikTok page dedicated to pack openings as well! https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC1Z9ZAc3Dv2QjPZBmkP6P0w

04/17/2026

Hey all! It's time to go back to school! Secrets of Strixhaven releases today! Preorders will be available for pickup at 12:00 pm today. We have a small teaser video of a collector pack opened by Will

03/27/2026

Hey all! MTG Pizza Bundle from Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles releases today. We have ours for 111.99! It contains 2 out of 6 possible promo cards with great reprints and new art, 9 booster packs, 1 collector booster pack. 25 pizza themed full art lands and a life counter dice!

03/24/2026

Hey all! We have Perfect Order available today for sale.
Booster Boxes - 221.49
Elite Trainer Box - 75.99
Booster Bundle - 42.99
Chikorita 3 Pack Blisters - 34.99
Booster Packs 9.49

03/13/2026

Hey all! We have our Secrets of Strixhaven Preorders available at MSRP! You can Preorder in store. Stop in anytime between now and Prerelease on Friday April 17th! Collector Booster Boxes limited to a qty of 2.
We will be running a Friday and Saturday prerelease event as well. Friday April 17th starting at 6:15pm and Saturday April 18th starting at 1:00 pm. Sign ups for the prerelease are available both in store and online.
https://graygauntletgames.com/products/secrets-of-strixhaven-friday-night-prerelease

02/09/2026

Hey all! We have Preorders available for Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle at MSRP! Preorders are available in store only. Stop in anytime between now and Prerelease.

Collector Booster Box - 455.88
Play Booster Box - 173.49
Bundle Box - 69.99
Commander Deck - 69.99

Friendly local game store in Fishers, IN. We carry MTG, Pokemon, FaB, WH40K, Board Games, RPGs, Dice, Minis, Paints, Geeky Gifts, and more!