Terry's Toffee

Terry's Toffee Gourmet toffee, gelato, confections, and coffee downtown Highland and online at terrystoffee.com Hand-crafted. Family-owned. Elevated ingredients.

Following a recipe passed down from Terry’s Grandmother McCall, we make artisanal toffee with the best ingredients we can source from our partners around the world. We have expanded on the family recipe to include inventive toffee flavors, as well as pairings with biscotti, ice cream and popcorn. From our family-owned brick and mortar shop in Chicago, we are committed to making every batch by hand, with all-natural ingredients and no additives. We hope you enjoy.

09/17/2026

We hand-toast the marshmallow. Because of course we do. 🔥🍫

S'mores Toffee starts with our classic buttery base, topped with a real marshmallow — torched right in the kitchen until it's golden and caramelized on the outside. Then the whole thing gets dipped in rich chocolate and left to set.

Cut it open and you'll see every layer and It tastes exactly like a campfire s'more mixed with toffee. Except since someone made it by hand in downtown Highland Park, it's objectively better.

This one is small batch— we don't always have it in stock. If you see it, grab it. That's not a warning. That's advice.

Come get it while it's here.

📍 1853 2nd St, Highland Park, IL
🛍️ TerrysToffee.com



smores toffee highland park | hand toasted marshmallow toffee | limited run toffee north shore | gourmet smores chocolate chicago | handcrafted toffee highland park il

Gelato shakes are now a thing. You're welcome. 🍦🥤We took our handcrafted gelato and turned it into something you absolut...
09/08/2026

Gelato shakes are now a thing. You're welcome. 🍦🥤

We took our handcrafted gelato and turned it into something you absolutely did not need in your life but are definitely going to order anyway. Three flavors. Zero apologies.

🍪 Biscoff — everything you love about that little cookie, in shake form
✨ Dubai — rich, indulgent, and worth every single sip
🍫 White Chocolate Raspberry — sweet, tart, and somehow perfectly balanced

Swipe through and pick your flavor. Then come in before we have to put these on the permanent menu and act like it was the plan all along.

Come get your shake.

📍 1853 2nd St, Highland Park, IL
🛍️ TerrysToffee.com



gelato shakes highland park | biscoff shake north shore | dubai chocolate shake | white chocolate raspberry shake | best milkshakes chicago | unique desserts highland park il

09/03/2026

You'll thank us for this later. 🍦🍬

Pistachio Gelato meets Pistachio Peppermint Toffee — and yes, we put them together on purpose. Creamy, nutty, with a cool peppermint finish from the toffee that makes the whole thing taste like dessert leveled up.

This is the collab nobody asked for and everyone needed.

Come try it before you have to hear about it from someone else.

📍 1853 2nd St, Highland Park, IL
🛍️ TerrysToffee.com



pistachio gelato highland park | pistachio peppermint toffee | gelato and toffee combo | best gelato north shore | unique desserts chicago

08/31/2026

Savor the last sips of summer. 🌸🍋

Our handcrafted lemonade spritzers are still here — and if summer is winding down, we think that's a very good reason to order one (or all three) before they're gone.

🌹 Strawberry Rose — fruity, floral, and a little fancy
🌿 Frosted Mint — cool, crisp, and basically a vibe
💜 Lavender — dreamy, delicate, and dangerously refreshing

Made in-house, right here in downtown Highland Park. The kind of drink that makes you want to sit in a yellow rocking chair and let the afternoon stretch out a little longer.

Come get your last sip of summer.

📍 1853 2nd St, Highland Park, IL
🛍️ TerrysToffee.com



strawberry rose lemonade highland park | lavender lemonade north shore | frosted mint lemonade | handcrafted lemonade chicago | best summer drinks highland park il

Love that the rocking chair post and this one are starting to connect into a little summer send-off series. Want to do one more to close out summer as a full campaign arc?

We're not saying toffee can fix everything. But we're not NOT saying that either. 🍫Custom trays of handcrafted toffee an...
08/29/2026

We're not saying toffee can fix everything. But we're not NOT saying that either. 🍫

Custom trays of handcrafted toffee and chocolate dipped gourmet treats — made fresh right here in downtown Highland Park using our family recipe.

Perfect for a shiva. A housewarming. A hostess gift. A "thank you." A "congratulations." A "I'm sorry honey, I have no idea what I was thinking." 💐

Whatever the occasion — or whatever you did — we can turn it around quickly and make you look really, really good.

Call us for details. We've got you.

📞 Call us to order
📍 1853 2nd St, Highland Park, IL
🛍️ TerrysToffee.com



custom toffee trays highland park | gourmet chocolate gifts north shore | handcrafted toffee gift trays chicago | shiva gifts highland park | housewarming gifts illinois

08/25/2026

Ooh, that one. Wait — that one. 🍓🫐🍑

Our sorbettos and fruity gelatos are here for the people who want something bright, fresh, and absolutely worth canceling plans for. Every flavor is exactly what it looks like — bold, fruity, and fresh served up right here in Highland Park.

Pick your flavor. We'll have a scoop ready.

📍 1853 2nd St, Highland Park, IL
🛍️ TerrysToffee.com



fruit sorbet highland park | fresh sorbet north shore | dairy free dessert chicago | best sorbet illinois | berry sorbet near me

08/20/2026

Have you ever seen naked toffee? 👀

Don't worry — we cover it up. Eventually.

Before it gets all dressed up in white chocolate, our Lemon Macadamia Toffee is packed with real macadamia nuts, golden and gorgeous on its own you just never get to see it like that.

Bright, buttery, a little tropical, and completely impossible to put down. This one tastes like summer decided to become a toffee.

Come get a piece.

📍 1853 2nd St, Highland Park, IL
🛍️ TerrysToffee.com



lemon macadamia toffee | white chocolate toffee highland park | macadamia nut toffee north shore | handcrafted toffee chicago | summer toffee flavors illinois

08/17/2026

We know what your plans should be... and it includes a fresh scoop of gelato! Terry's Toffee downtown HP has summer date night vibes! After dinner, after a movie, or just because nothing is sweeter than a cool treat on a hot summer night!

We have new fresh flavors on rotation! So there's something new to try every time you stop in!

📍 1853 2nd St, Highland Park, IL
🛍️ TerrysToffee.com



gelato highland park | best gelato north shore | gelato flavors chicago | weekend dessert plans | terry's toffee gelato

We don't usually compare toffee to wine. This one earned it. 🍷✨Limited run — Toasted Sesame Toffee! It starts with our c...
08/15/2026

We don't usually compare toffee to wine. This one earned it. 🍷✨

Limited run — Toasted Sesame Toffee! It starts with our classic family recipe, dipped in milk chocolate, finished with toasted sesame seeds folded right into every bite. Toasty up front, sweet in the middle, and a savory note at the end that lingers just long enough to make you go back for another piece.

It's nuanced. It's a little unexpected. It's a limited run — once it's gone, it's gone.

Come taste what we mean.

📍 1853 2nd St, Highland Park, IL
🛍️ TerrysToffee.com



toasted sesame toffee | new toffee flavor highland park | milk chocolate toffee | limited edition toffee north shore | handcrafted toffee illinois

08/12/2026

Make a cotton candy milkshake with us. 🩷🌀

Fluffy. Sweet. Completely over the top in the best possible way. This is not a drill — this is a milkshake that tastes exactly like childhood but better, because you're an adult who can have dessert whenever you want.

Come in and build one for yourself.

📍 1853 2nd St, Highland Park, IL
🛍️ TerrysToffee.com



cotton candy milkshake highland park | milkshake north shore | unique milkshakes chicago | terry's toffee milkshake | best milkshake illinois

Address

1853 2nd Street
Highland Park, IL
60035

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 8pm
Tuesday 11am - 8pm
Wednesday 11am - 8pm
Thursday 11am - 8pm
Friday 11am - 9:30pm
Saturday 10:30am - 9:30pm
Sunday 10:30am - 6pm

Telephone

+13127332700

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Terry's Toffee posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category