The Toy Pit

The Toy Pit Indy’s Biggest Toy & Collectibles Store! We BUY toys, collectibles & nostalgia from the ’70s to today. We have items for nearly every fandom at all price ranges!
(559)

Action Figures • Funko • Barbie • Monster High • Bratz • Pokémon • Video Game & Anime Collectibles • Vintage
Across from the Indiana State Fairgrounds. The Toy Pit offers the largest Inventory of Action Figures & Collectibles in Indianapolis! Items for Hardcore and New collectors! WE PAY CASH! The ONLY spot to go that can handle your large collection! Whether your collection requires a 15 foot box

truck or is just a few action figures - WE ARE READY! NO COLLECTION IS TOO BIG OR TOO SMALL! Star Wars, Marvel, GI Joe, WWE, DC, Power Rangers, Transformers, Hot Toys, NECA, Mezco One:12, Barbie, Funko Pops, Dragon Ball Z, TMNT, MOTU, Video Games, Records, Vintage T-Shirts and More!

We’ve hard a very busy start to our morning here at the shop! Tons of new SHF figures and a very decent amount of statue...
09/11/2026

We’ve hard a very busy start to our morning here at the shop! Tons of new SHF figures and a very decent amount of statues! A massive Lego lot came as well and all the sets are sealed🙌 The team is currently processing everything but if you have any questions or interest please contact us! We are here until 6PM today!

We are always BUYING and TRADING 🙌🙌

🙌
🙌
🙌
The Toy Pit’s new 13,000 Square Foot Mega Store is located only a half mile from the Indiana State Fairgrounds! We NEVER stop buying! No collection is too large for us! We can handle anything! Vintage/Modern + New/Used!

(317)703-8697 / (317)703-TOYS
3827 N College Ave Indianapolis, IN 46205
Tuesday-Friday • 11:00-6:30
Saturday • 10:30-6:00
Sunday • 12:00-6:00

Attention everyone! We will be hosting our first pinball event this Saturday! Our new friend Len was kind enough to help...
09/10/2026

Attention everyone! We will be hosting our first pinball event this Saturday! Our new friend Len was kind enough to help us make this happen! The team is well aware of how many of our customers and neighbors enjoy our pinball machines! Definitely not going to want to miss out on this 👍 See everyone on Saturday!!!

🔥WE WILL HAVE PLENTY OF QUARTERS🔥

🙌
🙌
🙌
The Toy Pit’s new 13,000 Square Foot Mega Store is located only a half mile from the Indiana State Fairgrounds! We NEVER stop buying! No collection is too large for us! We can handle anything! Vintage/Modern + New/Used!

(317)703-8697 / (317)703-TOYS
3827 N College Ave Indianapolis, IN 46205
Tuesday-Friday • 11:00-6:30
Saturday • 10:30-6:00
Sunday • 12:00-6:00

Some cool new trade-ins this morning! Come see us, we’re open until 6:30!We are always BUYING and TRADING 🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌The Toy P...
09/10/2026

Some cool new trade-ins this morning! Come see us, we’re open until 6:30!

We are always BUYING and TRADING 🙌🙌

🙌
🙌
🙌
The Toy Pit’s new 13,000 Square Foot Mega Store is located only a half mile from the Indiana State Fairgrounds! We NEVER stop buying! No collection is too large for us! We can handle anything! Vintage/Modern + New/Used!

(317)703-8697 / (317)703-TOYS
3827 N College Ave Indianapolis, IN 46205
Tuesday-Friday • 11:00-6:30
Saturday • 10:30-6:00
Sunday • 12:00-6:00

First day back! Massive amounts of Marvel Legends, SHF, Lego, and much more is being processed at the moment! We did a l...
09/08/2026

First day back! Massive amounts of Marvel Legends, SHF, Lego, and much more is being processed at the moment! We did a live stream earlier, but if you were unable to join us then please feel free to reach out! We are here until 6:30 tonight! Come see what’s NEW 🔥🔥

We are always BUYING and TRADING ☝️☝️

🙌
🙌
🙌
The Toy Pit’s new 13,000 Square Foot Mega Store is located only a half mile from the Indiana State Fairgrounds! We NEVER stop buying! No collection is too large for us! We can handle anything! Vintage/Modern + New/Used!

(317)703-8697 / (317)703-TOYS
3827 N College Ave Indianapolis, IN 46205
Tuesday-Friday • 11:00-6:30
Saturday • 10:30-6:00
Sunday • 12:00-6:00

Crazy start to Sunday morning so far! Tons of trades have came through the door🔥 We’ve received a good amount of sealed ...
09/06/2026

Crazy start to Sunday morning so far! Tons of trades have came through the door🔥 We’ve received a good amount of sealed Pokemon products. Our SHF stock is currently high at the moment so don’t sleep on this opportunity! We are here until 6PM today! Give us a call if you have any questions ☎️

We are always BUYING and TRADING 🙌🙌

🙌
🙌
🙌
The Toy Pit’s new 13,000 Square Foot Mega Store is located only a half mile from the Indiana State Fairgrounds! We NEVER stop buying! No collection is too large for us! We can handle anything! Vintage/Modern + New/Used!

(317)703-8697 / (317)703-TOYS
3827 N College Ave Indianapolis, IN 46205
Tuesday-Friday • 11:00-6:30
Saturday • 10:30-6:00
Sunday • 12:00-6:00

Starting our Friday morning off right! Another massive Lego haul has landed at the shop 🙌 We’ve also been adding opened ...
09/04/2026

Starting our Friday morning off right! Another massive Lego haul has landed at the shop 🙌 We’ve also been adding opened complete sets to the cases all week! If you have any questions please feel free to contact us, we are here until 6:30pm tonight🚨

We are always BUYING and TRADING 🙌🙌

🙌
🙌
🙌
The Toy Pit’s new 13,000 Square Foot Mega Store is located only a half mile from the Indiana State Fairgrounds! We NEVER stop buying! No collection is too large for us! We can handle anything! Vintage/Modern + New/Used!

(317)703-8697 / (317)703-TOYS
3827 N College Ave Indianapolis, IN 46205
Tuesday-Friday • 11:00-6:30
Saturday • 10:30-6:00
Sunday • 12:00-6:00

Got a nice, clean lot of vintage Super Powers in early this morning! 💪Come by any time, we’re open until 6:30! 👏
09/03/2026

Got a nice, clean lot of vintage Super Powers in early this morning! 💪

Come by any time, we’re open until 6:30! 👏

Here until 6:30PM today! We have added tons of great new items! Lots of Marvel Legends, Lego, Funko Pops, WWE Elites, an...
09/02/2026

Here until 6:30PM today! We have added tons of great new items! Lots of Marvel Legends, Lego, Funko Pops, WWE Elites, and many more! We are still working diligently to add more as the day continues! If you have any questions or want to know about a specific item please let us know! The team hopes everyone is having a wonderful start to their week ☝️☝️

We are always BUYING and TRADING 🙌🙌

🙌
🙌
🙌
The Toy Pit’s new 13,000 Square Foot Mega Store is located only a half mile from the Indiana State Fairgrounds! We NEVER stop buying! No collection is too large for us! We can handle anything! Vintage/Modern + New/Used!

(317)703-8697 / (317)703-TOYS
3827 N College Ave Indianapolis, IN 46205
Tuesday-Friday • 11:00-6:30
Saturday • 10:30-6:00
Sunday • 12:00-6:00

Tons of new stuff landing this Tuesday morning! The crew is here and working hard to get everything processed and ready ...
09/01/2026

Tons of new stuff landing this Tuesday morning! The crew is here and working hard to get everything processed and ready to go!! It’s a wonderful day to get out of the house and pick something cool up for your collection 👍 We are here until 6:30pm tonight!!

We are always BUYING and TRADING 🙌🙌

🙌
🙌
🙌
The Toy Pit’s new 13,000 Square Foot Mega Store is located only a half mile from the Indiana State Fairgrounds! We NEVER stop buying! No collection is too large for us! We can handle anything! Vintage/Modern + New/Used!

(317)703-8697 / (317)703-TOYS
3827 N College Ave Indianapolis, IN 46205
Tuesday-Friday • 11:00-6:30
Saturday • 10:30-6:00
Sunday • 12:00-6:00

Chat what do we think? Newest edition to our wall of murals! Huge thanks to Mike Palmore Martin for getting this done 🔥🔥...
08/29/2026

Chat what do we think? Newest edition to our wall of murals! Huge thanks to Mike Palmore Martin for getting this done 🔥🔥 Let us know who we should put on the wall next!!

🙌
🙌
🙌
The Toy Pit’s new 13,000 Square Foot Mega Store is located only a half mile from the Indiana State Fairgrounds! We NEVER stop buying! No collection is too large for us! We can handle anything! Vintage/Modern + New/Used!

(317)703-8697 / (317)703-TOYS
3827 N College Ave Indianapolis, IN 46205
Tuesday-Friday • 11:00-6:30
Saturday • 10:30-6:00
Sunday • 12:00-6:00

Address

3827 N College Avenue
Indianapolis, IN
46205

Opening Hours

Tuesday 11am - 6:30pm
Wednesday 11am - 6:30pm
Thursday 11am - 6:30pm
Friday 11am - 6:30pm
Saturday 10:30am - 6pm
Sunday 12pm - 6pm

Telephone

+13177038697

Website

,

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Toy Pit posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Toy Pit:

Shortcuts

Share

Category