Fan Cave Indy

Fan Cave Indy Your local card shop! We have sealed wax, singles, supplies, Pokémon and more. Family friendly!

1 DAY AWAY! Don't miss your chance to meet Colts Tanor Bortolini THURSDAY from 6:00 - 7:30pm at Fan Cave! Tickets are be...
09/02/2026

1 DAY AWAY! Don't miss your chance to meet Colts Tanor Bortolini THURSDAY from 6:00 - 7:30pm at Fan Cave! Tickets are being sold first come first serve, so get here early! Can't wait to see you there!

DATE CHANGE!!! Due to a scheduling conflict the Tanor Bortolini signing will now be Thursday, September 3rd at 6:00pm! D...
08/27/2026

DATE CHANGE!!! Due to a scheduling conflict the Tanor Bortolini signing will now be Thursday, September 3rd at 6:00pm! Don't miss out on a chance to meet Tanor!

Excited to announce we will be Hosting Tanor Bortolini at Fan Cave Indy right before Colts season kicks off! Purchase ti...
08/19/2026

Excited to announce we will be Hosting Tanor Bortolini at Fan Cave Indy right before Colts season kicks off! Purchase tickets today or come by the shop to see if you can hunt down one of the free ones hidden around the store! Tickets are limited so get them before they are gone!

Chase the new young stars in 2026 Select Racing! Hobby boxes in store now!
06/17/2026

Chase the new young stars in 2026 Select Racing! Hobby boxes in store now!

Need to rip some Magic? We have plenty of it for you in stock now!
06/13/2026

Need to rip some Magic? We have plenty of it for you in stock now!

Come rip the newest line of WNBA Select products, with Hobby Mega Boxes releasing today and Hobby Boxes and Hobby Blaste...
05/29/2026

Come rip the newest line of WNBA Select products, with Hobby Mega Boxes releasing today and Hobby Boxes and Hobby Blasters in stock!

Chase top prospects and Stained Class short-prints in the new 2026 Panini Donruss Baseball hobby boxes, in stock now! ...
05/28/2026

Chase top prospects and Stained Class short-prints in the new 2026 Panini Donruss Baseball hobby boxes, in stock now!

2025 Select WNBA Hobby & Blaster Boxes are now in stock!
05/22/2026

2025 Select WNBA Hobby & Blaster Boxes are now in stock!

With the 2026 World Cup beginning next month, it’s the perfect time to begin your collectiok of the NEW 2026 Panini Worl...
05/18/2026

With the 2026 World Cup beginning next month, it’s the perfect time to begin your collectiok of the NEW 2026 Panini World Cup Sticker Collection!

Albums, Sticker Packs, and 25-Pack Boxes are available now!

Chase the hot new prospects and big league call-ups with 2026 Bowman Baseball! In stock now!
05/13/2026

Chase the hot new prospects and big league call-ups with 2026 Bowman Baseball! In stock now!

Address

4805 Madison Avenue
Indianapolis, IN
46227

Opening Hours

Monday 12pm - 5:30pm
Tuesday 12pm - 5:30pm
Wednesday 10am - 5:30pm
Thursday 10am - 5:30pm
Friday 10am - 5:30pm
Saturday 10am - 5pm

Telephone

+13174264921

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Fan Cave Indy posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Fan Cave Indy:

Shortcuts

Share

Category