Wish I Kept It: A Pop Culture Shop

Wish I Kept It: A Pop Culture Shop Wish I Kept It is a pop culture shop full of vintage toys, comic books, CDs, DVDs, etc.

My three favorites from the TOG line!
05/25/2025

My three favorites from the TOG line!

A clown is born! 🤡
05/18/2025

A clown is born! 🤡

Custom MOTU Hulk Rage Cage!
08/18/2024

Custom MOTU Hulk Rage Cage!

Red Ded Rex: Bounty Hunter for Hire!
08/03/2024

Red Ded Rex: Bounty Hunter for Hire!

Found the two I wanted the most! Kevin Nash and the Fake Diesel (Kane)
07/15/2024

Found the two I wanted the most! Kevin Nash and the Fake Diesel (Kane)

I cannot believe it but Walmart actually delivered!
07/13/2024

I cannot believe it but Walmart actually delivered!

The last two at my local Target today! One to open and one to keep sealed!
05/04/2024

The last two at my local Target today! One to open and one to keep sealed!

Custom Horde Trooper prime (just finished)
03/30/2024

Custom Horde Trooper prime (just finished)

Custom MOTU Venom!
03/30/2024

Custom MOTU Venom!

Custom WWE Superstars King Kong Bundy! Five!!!!
02/26/2024

Custom WWE Superstars King Kong Bundy! Five!!!!

Address

17 North Center Street
Millerton, NY
12546

Opening Hours

Friday 11am - 6pm
Saturday 11am - 5pm

Telephone

+18603079809

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Wish I Kept It: A Pop Culture Shop posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Wish I Kept It: A Pop Culture Shop:

Shortcuts

Share

Category