Tough Lures Old Antique Vintage Fishing Lures For Sale

Home
United States
Milroy, PA
Tough Lures Old Antique Vintage Fishing Lures For Sale

I buy and sell old, vintage and antique fishing lures. Visit my website for loads of lures for sale! I buy, sell, trade and identify Old Fishing Lures!

I am interested in most companies such as Heddon, Creek Chub, Paw Paw, Pflueger, South Bend, Shakespeare, and tons of other miscellaneous companies. I am adding new lures for sale on my website all the time so keep checking back because you never know what I may find. If you have any lures you would like to sell, please contact me and I will be happy to take a look at what you have. I buy individual lures or entire collections. I am always looking for Heddon, Creek Chub, Shakespeare, Paw Paw, Pflueger, Donaly, and more! I pretty much look for any rare old lures!

09/18/2026

Hot off the press is this tough to find Vintage Shakespeare Baby Revolution Lure. You don't find this size very often and will want to sn**ch this one up quickly! To be the new lucky owner, go to the link below.

https://toughlures.com/collections/shakespeare-lures-for-sale/products/shakespeare-baby-revolution-5

09/18/2026

Just listed on Tough Lures is this Heddon Early Pal-On Nylon Tapered Fly Line In The Correctly Labeled Box. This is such a tough to find combo! If you need this for your collection, go to the link below.

https://toughlures.com/collections/heddon-lures-for-sale/products/heddon-early-pal-on-nylon-tapered-fly-line-in-box

09/17/2026

Just listed on our site is a super rare Cane River Bait Co Johnny Horton Galloping A. You very rarely see one of these and to get a chance to add one to your collection is almost unheard of. If you would love to add this to your lure display, go to the link below. This one will not last long!

https://toughlures.com/collections/all-lures-for-sale/products/cane-river-bait-co-johnny-horton-galloping-a

09/14/2026

Have a look at this South Bend Pike Scale Baby Pike Oreno we have available on our site. The lure comes in the Correctly Marked Original Box with the Good Luck Tokens Insert. If this is a combo you have been looking for, go to the link below to make it yours!

https://toughlures.com/collections/south-bend-lures-for-sale/products/south-bend-pike-scale-baby-pike-oreno-in-box-956-p

09/14/2026

Recently added to our site is this pair of vintage H.C. Brush Yellow and Red Float Trolling Spoons. These are pretty scarce New York made lures. If you want to add these toughies to your collection, go to the link below.

https://toughlures.com/collections/all-lures-for-sale/products/h-c-brush-yellow-and-red-float-trolling-spoon-pair

09/13/2026

We have this beautiful Bagley Copper Foil Shad CFS Small Fry Deep Diver Sealed On The Card on our site and ready for a new home. This is a desirable and fairly tough to find color. You don't see it on the card like this very often. To make this beauty yours, go to the link below.

https://toughlures.com/collections/misc-lures-for-sale/products/bagley-copper-foil-shad-cfs-small-fry-deep-diver-on-card

09/13/2026

We have some great vintage Pflueger Neverfail Minnows on our site! These are tough white eye models and desirable colors, too. If you want to add one, two or three of these to your collection, go to the link below to see these and more Pflueger lures we have!

https://toughlures.com/collections/pflueger-lures-for-sale

09/12/2026

Don't miss your chance to own this tough to find Western Auto lure box we have available! These aren't coming around very often these days. If you want to add this to your collection, go to the link below.

https://toughlures.com/collections/creek-chub-lures-for-sale/products/western-auto-western-fishing-lures-empty-box-v5022

09/12/2026

Here is a really cool old Stenciled Otter Live Bait Worm Box we have on our site. I have never seen one of these before! If you have a great place to display this and would love to have it, go to the link below.

https://toughlures.com/collections/all-lures-for-sale/products/otter-stenciled-worm-live-bait-box

09/11/2026

Here is a great vintage Lazy Ike Metallic Green Head Sail Shark In The Original Box we have listed. It is one of two different chrome colors we have available. To have a look, go to the link below.

https://toughlures.com/collections/all-lures-for-sale/products/lazy-ike-metallic-green-head-sail-shark-in-box-200-mg

Address

PO Box 685
Milroy, PA
17063

Telephone

+17176670134

Website

https://toughlures.com/collections/all-lures-for-sale

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Tough Lures Old Antique Vintage Fishing Lures For Sale posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Tough Lures Old Antique Vintage Fishing Lures For Sale:

Want your business to be the top-listed Shop in Milroy?

Tough Lures Old Antique Vintage Fishing Lures For Sale

09/18/2026

09/18/2026

09/17/2026

09/14/2026

09/14/2026

09/13/2026

09/13/2026

09/12/2026

09/12/2026

09/11/2026

Address

Telephone

Website

Alerts

Contact The Business

Shortcuts

Share

Listing takedown request