Pit & Pendulum Subculture Shop

Pit & Pendulum Subculture Shop Long Island’s ONLY CURATED brick&mortar experience for horror / physical media / underground music subcultures.

Every day is Halloween & we bring 40+ yrs of collecting 80’s-90’s toys, records, tapes, VHS, comics/zines & more for spooky kids of ALL AGES!

08/10/2026
07/20/2026

Pit & Pendulum is the strange little dream of Adrienne & John M. DeSantis — two lifelong lovers of Halloween, horror, music, movies & all things wonderfully weird.

Adrienne & John first met on vacation as little kids, long before they knew they would eventually spend 20+ years together building a life, a family, and a crazy collection of obscure treasures that slowly took over their home.

For our family (and maybe yours?!), Halloween is not just one day a year . . .

IT IS OUR LIFE.

* It lives in all the strange little moments that make us happiest.

* It is ever-present in the media & films we consume — and the music that gives us chills.

* It drives every single design & decor decision we make.

And now, after four decades hiding in the shadows, it is a beacon of light for our community — reflected in every corner of our shop & the unique items we curate for our shelves.

John has been collecting records, movies, books, toys & oddities for his entire life of 47 years — obsessively drawn to the unusual, the forgotten, the spooky, and the hard-to-find.

Adrienne has been right there with him, leveraging her own passion for interior design to help manifest that lifelong obsession into the physical realm — to build something unique they could share with others.

Our daughters, Talulah & Paloma, inherited the family love of Halloween, creepy/cute things & anything with a ‘lil dose of magic, mystery, or mischief!

As our shop inspiration Edgar Allan Poe said: “There is no exquisite beauty . . . without some strangeness in the proportion.”

P&P now finally exists for EVERYONE who finds beauty in the strange, comfort in the unpredictable & uncomfortable, and joy in the discovery of something they didn’t even know they were searching for.

Welcome to The Pit — we’ve been dying to meet you.

🫀

(“Our Story” written by John & Adrienne, by hand, without the use of artificial intelligence. We believe AI is simply another tool — NOT something that should dictate our experiences within the creative realm. We are human beings, artists, curators & collectors — not machines)

Address

219 Merrick Road
Oceanside, NY
11572

Opening Hours

Wednesday 12pm - 5pm
Thursday 12pm - 5pm
Friday 12pm - 7pm
Saturday 12pm - 7pm
Sunday 12pm - 4pm

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Pit & Pendulum Subculture Shop posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share