Replay It Retro

09/26/2026

09/23/2026

Looking for Pokémon? Check out recent in stock items.

09/19/2026

🌧️ Rainy Saturday? Come hang out with us! 🎮

Replay It Retro is OPEN today from 10 AM–3 PM!

Just a heads-up — we’re short staffed again today, so we may not be able to process large trades while you wait. If you’re bringing in a larger trade, we may need to have you leave it with us and arrange pickup once we’ve had time to go through everything.

We appreciate your patience and understanding! ❤️

📍 Replay It Retro
209 W. Michigan Ave.
Paw Paw, MI 49079

🕙 Saturday: 10 AM–3 PM

Stop in, stay dry, and browse some games, Pokémon, collectibles & more! 🎮

09/18/2026

The trades have been coming in! 🎮🔥
Lots of great stuff hitting the shelves lately — from retro favorites to newer titles.

👀 See anything you’re looking for?

09/12/2026

🍷🍇 W**e & Harvest Festival Weekend Heads Up!

With a busy festival weekend ahead, Replay It Retro will be operating with a smaller crew than usual.

📍209 West Michigan Avenue
Paw Paw, MI 49079

Open Saturdays 10:00am-3:00pm

🎮 Bringing in a trade? We’ll still be accepting trades, but large trades may need to be left with us and picked up later in the week or next Saturday.

If you have a larger collection, we recommend waiting until after festival weekend if possible.

Thanks for understanding — and stop in and see us while you’re downtown! 🎮

09/12/2026

🎮 NEW at Replay It Retro! 🎮

We’ve been having some fun with the 3D printers and now have some of our prints available in the store!

We’re starting with gaming-inspired keychains, including Mario, Luigi, Minecraft, PlayStation, retro gaming designs and more — with new ones being added as we make them.

Most keychains are just $4 each!

Stop in and check them out next time you’re at the store. And if these are a hit, we may have to keep the printers busy! 👀

📍 Replay It Retro
209 West Michigan Avenue
Paw Paw, MI 49079

09/09/2026

Okay retro gamers… you can only pick ONE. 🎮

NES, SNES, N64, Famicom or SNES Jr. — which one are you taking home? 👇

09/07/2026

🇺🇸 Happy Labor Day from Replay It Retro! 🎮

We are CLOSED today for Labor Day.

We hope everyone has a safe and relaxing holiday! We’ll see you when we reopen! ❤️🤍💙

09/02/2026

The answer for this week's trivia question is: 1989! The Genesis went on to become one the best selling systems of the 16-bit era and was a big competitor to Nintendo, we happen to have Two Sega Genesis consoles here in the store a Model 1 and Model 2!

Come in this week and check them out along with our great selection of Genesis games.

09/02/2026

You walk into a retro game store and realize… this is only the FIRST room. 👀🎮

Pokémon, Atari, Sega, consoles, plush, accessories and a whole lot more packed into our front showroom.

And we're just getting started. 😏

What section are you heading to first? 👇