What are the opening hours?

Monday 12pm - 7pm Tuesday 12pm - 7pm Wednesday 12pm - 7pm Thursday 12pm - 7pm Friday 12pm - 8:30pm Saturday 12pm - 7pm Sunday 12pm - 6pm

All In One Collectibles

Home
United States
Randolph, NJ
All In One Collectibles

One of the largest stores on the East Coast. Over 6500 square feet filled with everything Collectible. Sports Cards, Toys, Comics, Pokémon and tons more...

All In One Collectibles is New Jersey's premier Gaming, Sportscards, Comic Book and Collectibles store. Wi-Fi available

Event Schedule

Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday:

Friday Night Magic Commander - 6:30 - 9pm
$5 Entry - 1 pack with entry, pack per player in prize pool

Saturday
Sunday

05/08/2026

New releases!

05/05/2026

LIVE Auction tonight at from 7pm-9pm
70 Premium Lot - Sportscards & More!!

LOT # ITEM DESCRIPTION OPEN BID
1 (24) NY Yankees 1st Day Covers Z-Folio in Binder $10.00
2 (24) NY Yankees 1st Day Covers Z-Folio in Binder $10.00
3 (24) NY Yankees 1st Day Covers Z-Folio in Binder $10.00
4 (36) Brooklyn Dodgers 1st Day Covers Z-Folio in Binder $12.00
5 (80+) Dodgers Post Cards In Binder $10.00
6 NY Mets Mixed Lot Cards/Yearbook + $5.00
7 (3) Super Star Statues Figures Gooden/Canseco/Straw $10.00
8 (2) 1989 Donruss Baseballs' Best Complete Sets in box $20.00
9 1998 Score Baseball Sealed Box (60) Card Box $6.00
10 1989 Score Traded Baseball Set Griffey Jr RC $6.00
11 1987 Fleer Update Baseball Set Maddux RC $5.00
12 (2) 1991 Topps Traded Baseball Sets Loaded with RC's $7.00
13 3000+ Basketball Cards In 3 Row box $5.00
14 5000 ct Box of Baseball Mixed years with stars $5.00
15 5000 ct Box of Baseball Mixed years with stars $5.00
16 Big Box of Football With Stars & Rookies $5.00
17 (80+) 1981 Topps Baseball With Stars & Rookies $5.00
18 (70+) 1979 Topps Baseball With Stars & Rookies $10.00
19 (40 1978 Topps Baseball With Stars & Rookies $8.00
20 (80+) 1970's-80's Dodgers With stars $7.00
21 (80+) 1970's-80's Topps Reds With Stars $7.00
22 (80+) 1970's-80's Phillies With Stars $7.00
23 (80+) 1970's-80's Expos With Stars $7.00
24 (80+) 1970's-80's Cubs With Stars $7.00
25 (80+) 1970's-80's Cardinals With Stars $7.00
26 (80+) 1970's-80's Pirates With Stars $7.00
27 (80+) 1970's-80's Angels With Stars $7.00
28 (80+) 1970's-80's Twins With Stars $7.00
29 (80+) 1970's-80's Indians With Stars $7.00
30 (80+) 1970's-80's A's With Stars $7.00
31 (80+) 1970's-80's Brewers With Stars $7.00
32 (80+) 1970's-80's Tigers With Stars $7.00
33 (80+) 1970's-80's Orioles With Stars $7.00
34 (80+) 1970's-80's Red Sox With Stars $7.00
35 (80+) 1970's-80's Astros With Stars $7.00
36 (80+) 1970's-80's White Sox With Stars $7.00
37 (80+) 1970's-80's Padres With Stars $7.00
38 (60+) 1970's-80's Braves With Stars $5.00
39 (70+) 1970's-80's Giants With Stars $5.00
40 (80+) 1970's-80's Royals With Stars $7.00
41 (80+) 1970's-80's Rangers With Stars $7.00
42 Big Box of Basketball Cards Stars/Rookies/Inserts $5.00
43 3 Sports Card Binders $5.00
44 (250+)1978 Topps Baseball Nice range of cards $5.00
45 (300+) 1974 Topps Baseball Good Assortment $5.00
46 (400+)1979 Topps Baseball Wide Range of Cards $5.00
47 Box of Baseball Cards Stars/Rookies $5.00
48 Box of Baseball Cards Stars/Rookies $5.00
49 Box of Football Cards Stars/Rookies $5.00
50 2 open boxes Chrome Baseball 2020/2021 $6.00
51 Box of Basketball Cards Stars and Rookies $5.00
52 (15) 1994 Post Baseball Sets New in Package $6.00
53 Tons of Showdown Baseball Cards With Binder $5.00
54 (500+) 1980 Topps Baseball Wide variety of Cards $5.00
55 (300+)1975-1977 Topps Baseball Assorted Cards $5.00
56 Baseball Binder Card Pages Stars/Inserts $5.00
57 Basketball Binder Card Pages Stars/Inserts $5.00
58 (100+) 1972 Topps Baseball With High #'s $6.00
59 (100+)1972 Topps Baseball With Stars $5.00
60 (400+)1981 Topps Baseball Nice Assortment $5.00
61 2 Binder of Basketball Cards Tons of Rookies/Inserts $7.00
62 Loaded Binder of Baseball Game Used/ #'d/Stars ++ $30.00
63 Ernie Banks Topps Baseball Tin With Cards $8.00
64 (10) Minor League Baseball Team Sets 1990-91 Asst. Teams $5.00
65 2001 Pedro Martinez Bobble Head Donruss 2001 with Card $5.00
66 2001 Jeff Bagwell Bobble Head Donruss 2001 with Card $5.00
67 (2) Roger Clemens Bobbleheads Subway Series in box $6.00
68 (2) 1991 Score Traded Baseball Sets New in Box $5.00
69 Huge Grab Box of Stuff All Sports +++ $5.00
70 Box of Nascar Cards Tons of Great Drivers $5.00

04/21/2026

Insane pull out of a dawn wings necrozma box from XY Breakthrough by !!

04/14/2026

Original Dragon Ball Super cards priced and out now!

04/08/2026

Store remodeling has come a long way since we started a few months ago...even more to come!!

03/31/2026

Tons of new sports cards products just got restocked...Topps Baseball blasters/megas, Optics Football blasters/megas, Topps Basketball blasters & more!! 100's of great single cards just came in too...

03/20/2026

Nearly 10,000 new back issue comics will be out in the Comic Cave at All In One within the next week. Keys, Silver age, Runs of modern titles, $1 boxes and Graded books.

03/19/2026

Squishables in store now!!

03/07/2026

Upper Deck Series 2 Hockey "In Stock Now"

03/01/2026

LIVE Auction Tuesday March 3rd 7-9pm. 70 Premium Lots.

LOT # ITEM DESCRIPTION OPEN BID
1 Box of Basketball Cards Stars/Rookies/Inserts $5.00
2 Box of Baseball Cards Stars/Rookies/Inserts $5.00
3 Box of Basketball Cards Stars/Rookies/Inserts $5.00
4 Box of Football Cards Stars/Rookies/Inserts $5.00
5 Box of Football Cards Stars/Rookies/Inserts $5.00
6 Huge Lot of MLB ShowdownBaseball With binder $5.00
7 Box of Basketball Cards Stars/Rookies/Inserts $5.00
8 (5) Star Wars Figures Vader,Obi Wan ++ $10.00
9 (7) Star Wars Figures Leia/Lando +++ $14.00
10 Box of Football Cards Stars/Rookies/Inserts $5.00
11 Box of Basketball Cards Stars/Rookies/Inserts $5.00
12 Box of Basketball Cards Stars/Rookies/Inserts $5.00
13 Box of Basketball Cards Stars/Rookies/Inserts $5.00
14 Box of Basketball Cards Stars/Rookies/Inserts $5.00
15 Big Binder of Hockey Cards Tons of Stars $6.00
16 Box of Baseball Cards Stars/Rookies/Inserts $5.00
17 Big Box of Non Sports Rocketeer/Dino/Indiana $5.00
18 Mixed Lot of Oddball Baseball Griffey +++ $7.00
19 Catfish Hunter Autograph Card 1993 Nabisco $8.00
20 Ernie Banks Autographed Card 1993 Nabisco $12.00
21 12" Babe Ruth Starting Lineup Loose $6.00
22 12" Lou Gehrig Starting Lineup Loose $6.00
23 Lou Gehrig McFarlane Loose $5.00
24 Box of Assorted Sports Stuff Figures/Ornaments ++ $6.00
25 (16) Baseball Autograph Cards Rookies/Numbered ++ $8.00
26 Johnny Podres Autographed Baseball CAS Authentication $8.00
27 (18) 1970-72 Topps Baseball Hall of Famers & Stars $8.00
28 (18) 1972 Topps Baseball All High #'s $8.00
29 (18) 1972 Topps Baseball All High #'s $10.00
30 (9) 1972 Topps Baseball All High #'s $5.00
31 (9) 1972 Topps Baseball Hall of Famers & Stars $10.00
32 (2) Topps Hockey Sets 92-93 & 97-98 $5.00
33 (18) Leaf Football Autographs All Different $6.00
34 (15) Football Autographs All Different $5.00
35 1973 Topps Roberto Clemente Card #50 $7.00
36 1973 Topps Home Run Leaders Card #1 $8.00
37 Box of Football Cards Stars/Rookies/Inserts $5.00
38 Pile of Assorted Baaeball Sets/Topps ++ $6.00
39 (6) 1963 Topps Baseball With High #'s $7.00
40 (6) 1963 Topps Baseball With High #'s $7.00
41 (9) 1973 Topps Baseball Hall of Fame & Stars $5.00
42 (9) 1973 Topps Baseball Hall of Fame & Stars $5.00
43 (9) 1973 Topps Baseball Hall of Fame & Stars $7.00
44 (21) 1975 Topps Baseball Hall of Fame & Stars $8.00
45 (27) 1978 Topps NY Yankees All Different $6.00
46 (36) 1976-79 Topps NY Yankees All Different $6.00
47 (18) 1959 Topps Baseball With Stars $10.00
48 (18) Pokemon Cards Holos ++ $5.00
49 (18) Pokemon Cards Holos ++ $5.00
50 (54) Vintage Pokemon Cards In Pages $5.00
51 (54) Vintage Pokemon Cards In Pages $5.00
52 (40) Wayne Gretzky Cards Topps, Upper Deck ++ $5.00
53 (27) 1960-64 Topps Baseball With Stars $8.00
54 (18) 1963-64 Topps Baseball With Stars $20.00
55 (18) 1966-69 Topps Baseball With Stars $12.00
56 1965 Topps Orlando Cepeda Card #360 $5.00
57 1975 Topps Hank Aaron Card #660 $6.00
58 (27) 1970's-80's Topps Baseball Hall of Fame & Stars $8.00
59 (10) 1964-65 Topps Hockey All Different $7.00
60 (45) Vintage Pokemon Cards In Pages $5.00
61 (81) Pokemon Cards In Pages $5.00
62 (72) Pokemon Cards In Pages $5.00
63 Huge Box of Baseball Cards Tons of Stars $8.00
64 Box of Baseball Cards Tons of Stars $5.00
65 1980 Topps Superman II Cards Framed Display $6.00
66 Box of Mixed Sportscards Tons of Stars & Rookies $5.00
67 (32) 1977 Topps Star Wars Cards Series 4 Green $5.00
68 (42) 1977 Topps Star Wars Cards Series 5 Orange $6.00
69 (49) 1980 Topps Star Wars Cards Empire Strikes back $6.00
70 (47) 1977 Topps Star Wars Cards Series 2 Red $7.00

Address

540 State Route 10 Ste 2
Randolph, NJ
07869

Opening Hours

Monday	12pm - 7pm
Tuesday	12pm - 7pm
Wednesday	12pm - 7pm
Thursday	12pm - 7pm
Friday	12pm - 8:30pm
Saturday	12pm - 7pm
Sunday	12pm - 6pm

Telephone

(973) 664-0912

Website

http://www.allinonecollectibles.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when All In One Collectibles posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to All In One Collectibles:

Shortcuts

Address
Telephone
Opening Hours
Alerts
Contact The Business
Claim ownership or report listing

Want your business to be the top-listed Shop in Randolph?