All In One Collectibles

All In One Collectibles One of the largest stores on the East Coast. Over 6500 square feet filled with everything Collectible. Sports Cards, Toys, Comics, Pokémon and tons more...

All In One Collectibles is New Jersey's premier Gaming, Sportscards, Comic Book and Collectibles store. Wi-Fi available

Event Schedule

Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday:

Friday Night Magic Commander - 6:30 - 9pm
$5 Entry - 1 pack with entry, pack per player in prize pool

Saturday
Sunday

LIVE Auction Tuesday 9/1 at 7pm70 Premium Lots - Sportscards, Comics, Toys & More...LOT # ITEM DESCRIPTION OPEN BID1 Po...
08/29/2026

LIVE Auction Tuesday 9/1 at 7pm
70 Premium Lots - Sportscards, Comics, Toys & More...
LOT # ITEM DESCRIPTION OPEN BID
1 Pokemon Shadowless Pikachu Red Cheeks Error $5.00
2 Pokemon Japanese Meganium Holo Card #154 $5.00
3 Pokemon Base Set Ninetales Holo Card #12/102 $5.00
4 Pokemon Base Set Zapdos Holo Card #16/102 $5.00
5 Pokemon Base Set Magneton Holo Card #9/102 $5.00
6 Pokemon Base Set Mewtwo Holo Card #10/102 $5.00
7 Pokemon Base Set Chansey Holo Card #3/102 $5.00
8 Pokemon Base Set Hitmonchan Holo Card #7/102 $5.00
9 Pokemon Fossil Aerodactyl Holo Card #1/62 $5.00
10 Pokemon Fossil Hitmonlee Holo Card #7/62 $5.00
11 Pokemon Fossil Muk Holo Card #13/62 $5.00
12 Pokemon Fossil Lapras Holo Card #10/62 $5.00
13 Pokemon Charizard EX Promo Card $10.00
14 Pokemon Koga's Beedrill Holo Card #9/132 $5.00
15 Pokemon Misty's Seadra Holo Card #9/132 $5.00
16 1968 Topps Willie Mays Card #50 $10.00
17 1967 Topps Hank Aaron Card #250 $15.00
18 1969 Topps Tom Seaver Card #480 $7.00
19 1968 Topps Brooks Robinson Card #20 $5.00
20 1966 Topps Frank Robinson Card #310 $6.00
21 1978 Topps Molitor/Trammell RC Rookie Card #707 $5.00
22 1966 Topps Strikeout Leaders Koufax - Card #225 $5.00
23 (2) Open Topps Heritage Baseball Boxes 2020 & 2021 $5.00
24 Kakawow Disney Card Set Thanksgiving Themed $5.00
25 (18) Star Trex Next Generation Cards All Inserts $5.00
26 (18) Star Trex Next Generation Cards All Inserts $5.00
27 Huge Box of Magic Cards Great Assortment $40.00
28 Huge Box of Magic Cards Great Assortment $40.00
29 (2) Baseball Bobblehead Figures Piazza & Clemens $6.00
30 Derek Jeter Bobblehead Playmaker $6.00
31 (100) Assorted Pokemon Cards Great Assortment $5.00
32 (100) Assorted Pokemon Cards Great Assortment $5.00
33 (100) Assorted Pokemon Cards Great Assortment $5.00
34 (100) Assorted Pokemon Cards Great Assortment $5.00
35 (100) Assorted Pokemon Cards Great Assortment $5.00
36 (100) Assorted Pokemon Cards Great Assortment $5.00
37 (100) Assorted Pokemon Cards Great Assortment $5.00
38 (100) Assorted Pokemon Cards Great Assortment $5.00
39 (100) Assorted Pokemon Cards Great Assortment $5.00
40 (100) Assorted Pokemon Cards Great Assortment $5.00
41 Darth Vader Star Wars Bank In Box $10.00
42 (2) Dolls Barbie & Mary Kete In box $8.00
43 Tiki Barber Bobblehead NY Giants In Box $5.00
44 Batman Action Figure The Dark Knight $5.00
45 1968 Topps Jim Palmer Card #575 $5.00
46 Derek Jeter Signed 8x10 Photo Matted/Framed Steiner $150.00
47 Superboy #90 Graded Comic (1961) CGC Graded 8.5 $60.00
48 World's Finest #138 Graded Comic CGC Graded 7.5 $60.00
49 Teen Titans #5 Graded Comic (1966) CGC Graded 5.0 $40.00
50 Fantastic Four #36 Graded Comic CGC Graded 4.5 $60.00
51 1969 Topps Frank Robinson Card #250 $5.00
52 1969 Topps Harmon Killebrew Card #375 $5.00
53 1970 Topps Ted Williams Card #211 $5.00
54 1970 Topps Brooks Robinson Card #455 $5.00
55 1970 Topps Orlando Cepeda Card #555 $5.00
56 1970 Topps Catfish Hunter Card #565 $5.00
57 (2) Topps Joe Morgan 1971 & 1972 $5.00
58 (7) 1969-72 Topps baseball All HOF & Stars $10.00
59 (4) Baseball Sets Fleer & Donruss $6.00
60 (31) 1970-72 Topps Baseball Hall of Famers & Stars $10.00
61 (15) Vintage Comics Assorted Titles $8.00
62 (26) 1973 Topps Baseball Hall of Famers & Stars $7.00
63 (18) 1975 Topps MVP Baseball Mantle/Clemente/Mays++ $15.00
64 (36) 1976 Topps Baseball Hall of Famers & Stars $15.00
65 (26) 1971 Topps Baseball Hall of Famers & Stars $6.00
66 (5) 1971 Topps Baseball Hall of Famers & Stars $20.00
67 (45) 1979-80 Topps Hockey With Stars $5.00
68 (90+) 1981-82 Topps Hockey With Stars $5.00
69 (2) Bleachers Gold 23kt Cards E. Smith & Nolan Ryan $6.00
70 Earl Monroe Signed Photograph CAS Authentication $5.00

TOPPS CHROME UPDATE BASKETBALL IS HERE!! Limit one per person on hobby and blasters!
08/06/2026

TOPPS CHROME UPDATE BASKETBALL IS HERE!! Limit one per person on hobby and blasters!

TOPPS CHROME BASEBALL IS HERE!!!
07/22/2026

TOPPS CHROME BASEBALL IS HERE!!!

PITCH BLACK IS HERE!! Come down and check out our early release selection of Pokémon Pitch Black!
07/13/2026

PITCH BLACK IS HERE!! Come down and check out our early release selection of Pokémon Pitch Black!

NEW RELEASES!! Topps Chrome Black Football and Topps Finest Baseball are here!!
07/10/2026

NEW RELEASES!! Topps Chrome Black Football and Topps Finest Baseball are here!!

HUGE DRAGON SHIELD RESTOCK!! Every color we stock + more options available in store now
07/07/2026

HUGE DRAGON SHIELD RESTOCK!! Every color we stock + more options available in store now

CARDS OF THE WEEK. Welcome to the first edition of Cards of the Week, where we showcase some of our favorite cards headi...
07/07/2026

CARDS OF THE WEEK. Welcome to the first edition of Cards of the Week, where we showcase some of our favorite cards heading to the show floor this week!

LIVE Auction tomorrow Tuesday 7/7/267pm-9pm 70 Premium lotsLOT # ITEM DESCRIPTION OPEN BID1 1971 Topps Orioles Team Car...
07/06/2026

LIVE Auction tomorrow Tuesday 7/7/26
7pm-9pm 70 Premium lots
LOT # ITEM DESCRIPTION OPEN BID
1 1971 Topps Orioles Team Card Card #1 $5.00
2 1971 Topps Willie McCovey Card #50 $7.00
3 1971 Topps Steve Carlton Card #55 $7.00
4 1971 Topps Ted Simmons RC Rookie Card #117 $10.00
5 1971 Topps Billy Williams Card #350 $6.00
6 1982 Topps Cal Ripken Jr RC Rookie card #21 $15.00
7 1973 Topps Brooks Robinson Card #90 $6.00
8 1973 Topps Jim Palmer Card #160 $6.00
9 1973 Topps Frank Robinson Card #175 $6.00
10 1973 Topps Bob Gibson Card #190 $7.00
11 1973 Topps Carlton Fisk Card #193 $6.00
12 1973 Topps Carl Yastrzemski Card #245 $8.00
13 1973 Topps Willie McCovey Card #410 $5.00
14 1973 Topps Ty Cobb All Time Card #471 $5.00
15 1973 Topps Hank Aaron Card #473 $12.00
16 1973 Topps Ty Cobb All Time Card #475 $5.00
17 (2) Encases Leaf Basketball Autos Both Cards #'d $5.00
18 1974 Topps Frank Robinson Card #55 $5.00
19 1979-80 Topps Ken Dryden Card #150 $5.00
20 (45+) 1979-80 Topps Hockey With Stars $8.00
21 1975 Topps Joe Morgan Card #180 $6.00
22 1975 Topps MVP Mantle & Aaron Card #195 $6.00
23 1975 Topps Gary Carter RC Rookie Card #620 $8.00
24 1977 Topps Brooks Robinson Card #285 $5.00
25 (90+) 1981-82 Topps Hockey With Stars $5.00
26 Earl Monroe Signed Photo CAS Authenticated $5.00
27 (25+) Allen & Ginter Mini Cards All Non Sports $5.00
28 1995 Bleachers Gold Emmitt Smith 23kt Gold Limited Ed $5.00
29 1997 Zenith Football Promo Pack Sealed $5.00
30 1985 Topps Roger Clemens RC Rookie Card #181 $5.00
31 1992 Upper Deck Derek Jeter Minors card #5 $5.00
32 (2) 1987 Donruss Rookie Cards Bond & Bo Jackson $8.00
33 1983 Fleer Tony Gwynn RC Rookie Card #360 $6.00
34 (9) 1975 Topps MVP Baseball Mantle/Clemente ++ $15.00
35 (9) 1975 Topps MVP Baseball Mantle/Mays/Aaron $15.00
36 (6) Silver Age Comic Books Archie ++ $5.00
37 (6) Silver Age Comic Books Archie ++ $5.00
38 Star Trek Collectible Coffee Set New Factory Sealed $5.00
39 (3) Baseball Hobby Rip Night Packs New Factory Sealed $6.00
40 (17) 1975 Topps Baseball Hall of Famers & Stars $6.00
41 (16) 1975 Topps Baseball Hall of Famers & Stars $6.00
42 Binder Full of Pokemon cards 1st Ed, Foils +++ $15.00
43 (13) 1973 Topps Baseball Hall of Famers & Stars $5.00
44 (13) 1973 Topps Baseball Hall of Famers & Stars $5.00
45 (26) 1971 Topps Baseball With Hall of famers & Stars $8.00
46 2018 Topps All Star Aaron Judge Wrapper Redemption Card $7.00
47 Thor #164 Silver Age Comic Book 3rd App of Adam Warlock $7.00
48 (3) Vintage Comic Books Star Wars/FF/Power Man $7.00
49 Superman #151 Silver Age Comic Book From 1962 12 cent cover $5.00
50 (11) Vintage Comic Books Assorted Titles $7.00
51 (5) HESS Gas Trucks In Boxes $20.00
52 (33) Assorted Hot Wheels Nice assortment $15.00
53 (9) 1976 Topps Baseball Hall of Famers & Stars $5.00
54 (9) 1976 Topps Baseball Hall of Famers & Stars $6.00
55 (9) 1976 Topps Baseball Hall of Famers & Stars $8.00
56 (9) 1976 Topps Baseball Hall of Famers & Stars $5.00
57 (9) Modern Baseball Cards Game Used & Numbered $5.00
58 Highland Mint Ichiro Bronze Coin 1oz Bronze #1147/5000 $5.00
59 (31) 1970-72 Topps Baseball Hall of Famers & Stars $15.00
60 1996 Bleachers Gold Nolan Ryan 23kt Gold Limited Ed $5.00
61 (7) Assorted Sports Card Autographs All Pack pulled $5.00
62 (4) Boxes of Baseball Cards May include full sets $6.00
63 (5) Boxes of Baseball Cards May include full sets $6.00
64 (2) Binders of Football cards Tons of stars $7.00
65 (2) Binders of Baseball cards Tons of stars $7.00
66 Binder of Basketball Cards With Stars & Inserts $5.00
67 (83) 9 Pocket Pages of Baseball Loaded with Stars $10.00
68 Big Box of Sportscards Mixed Sports $7.00
69 Pile of Cards in snaps & Screwdowns Stars & Rookies $10.00
70 Box of Conlan Baseball Cards May be complete Set $5.00

NEW RELEASES! New Yugioh set Chaos Origins and OP-16 Time of Battle!!
07/03/2026

NEW RELEASES! New Yugioh set Chaos Origins and OP-16 Time of Battle!!

POKÉMON IS HERE! Come check out our new Mega Greninja EX Premium Collections and Prismatic Evolutions Poster Collections...
07/03/2026

POKÉMON IS HERE! Come check out our new Mega Greninja EX Premium Collections and Prismatic Evolutions Poster Collections!

Address

540 State Route 10 Ste 2
Randolph, NJ
07869

Opening Hours

Monday 12pm - 7pm
Tuesday 12pm - 7pm
Wednesday 12pm - 7pm
Thursday 12pm - 7pm
Friday 12pm - 8:30pm
Saturday 12pm - 7pm
Sunday 12pm - 6pm

Telephone

(973) 664-0912

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when All In One Collectibles posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to All In One Collectibles:

Shortcuts

Share

Category