Kayfabe Toys

Kayfabe Toys Buy & sell anything wrestling related

Main event for tonight’s auction! We also have a ton of in box Elites and Ultimates. Join us on Whatnot at 7pm CST
06/17/2026

Main event for tonight’s auction! We also have a ton of in box Elites and Ultimates. Join us on Whatnot at 7pm CST

👀 too many figures to choose from for tonight’s main event. See you all tonight on Whatnot at 6pm CST.
06/16/2026

👀 too many figures to choose from for tonight’s main event. See you all tonight on Whatnot at 6pm CST.

Yes, we have Jeff Hardy’s for tonight’s stream! See you all at 730pm CST on .
06/15/2026

Yes, we have Jeff Hardy’s for tonight’s stream! See you all at 730pm CST on .

We are buying DDP Ultimates and Elites! Is your Walmart cluttered with the Ultimates? We will buy them then hopefully th...
06/13/2026

We are buying DDP Ultimates and Elites! Is your Walmart cluttered with the Ultimates? We will buy them then hopefully they will restock new figures for you.

HUGE announcement! Kayfabe Toys will be at Bigeventny with The Great Khali. Mail ins will be announced at a later date.
06/13/2026

HUGE announcement! Kayfabe Toys will be at Bigeventny with The Great Khali. Mail ins will be announced at a later date.

$1 starts on belts today on starting at 12pm CST!
06/10/2026

$1 starts on belts today on starting at 12pm CST!

06/08/2026

If you have a collection you’d like to sell message us on Instagram or email at [email protected]

Address

Saint Croix Falls, WI
54024

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Kayfabe Toys posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Kayfabe Toys:

Shortcuts

Share

Category