07/01/2026
Here's the July Hooked on Books column in the Selma Times-Journal. I'm not trying to pot-stir, but sometimes you just can't help yourself. Enjoy. And a Happy Fourth to all!
I’ve always thought Socrates was on the mark when he said, “An unexamined life is not worth living.”
So how about this: “An unexamined faith is not worth having.”?
I was taught from an early age not to ask questions about the Bible. I obeyed. I sang “The B-I-B-L-E, yes that’s the book for me!” I went to Sunday School and dreamed about Mrs. Lukens’ flannelgraph depiction of the parting of the Red Sea. I even conjured up my own vision of Hell, where I was strapped on an ever-spinning rotisserie, while a sharp-clawed devil in a red leotard basted me in molten lava.
I was reminded how far those days were behind me when three books were dropped off at my bookstore this past month. These books--The Separation of Church and Hate by John Fugelsang; The Bible Says So by Dan McClellan; and Jesus and John Wayne by Kristin Kobes du Mez—would have set Mrs. Lukens’ hair ablaze.
Fugelsang examines the theology of Christian Nationalism. McClellan looks at “what we get right (and wrong) about the Bible.” And du Mez investigates militarism and patriarchy in the religious right. As I read the books I found myself agreeing with much of their evidence, placing myself squarely at odds with my old self, some of my neighbors, and not a few colleagues on this Opinion page.
My Christian faith continues to be a magnificent mystery, but, in our terribly divided culture, a faith that is pushed and pulled and manipulated until it sometimes seems as much a source of grief as joy. All this manipulation means that I often feel a need to ensure that my faith is well-grounded. I want to believe that the Bible translation my church advocates is as accurate as possible. I want to acknowledge when evidence about disputed theological sticking points has merit. I want to be able to admit when this evidence persuades me that a belief seemingly based in fear or a need for ideological control is no longer convincing.
And so, locally, as I watch one denomination wrestle over the idea of female pastors, as I see another fractured by anguished hair-splitting about sexual orientation, as I hear many around me reiterate how often they are discouraged about asking questions of their faith, I am even more convinced that we must not be afraid to challenge ourselves whenever the “old time religion” some of us sing about fails to provide adequate answers. Just because we realize we might have gotten something wrong about the Bible is not to invite Armageddon or put us on a glide path to atheism.
Going forward, I’m going to stick with Socrates and keep in mind a quote from Jewish theologian Abraham Joshua Heschel: “We are closer to God when we are asking questions than when we think we have the answers.”
Doesn’t that sound about right?
The owner of Selma’s Fair Oak Books, D.B.Tipmore is the author of My Little Town and the forthcoming novel, Barefoot Boy, to be published this fall by Rattling Good Yarns Press. He can be reached at [email protected]