09/04/2026
Here's "Fear of Fiction," the "Hooked on Books" column for the September Selma Times-Journal Opinion page. Thanks for giving it a moment.
Real men don’t read. Rather, real men don’t read fiction. Or they read it rarely. Science fiction, maybe, but simon-pure fiction? Don’t hold your breath. And not locally. At Fair Oaks Books, men investigate the fiction shelves about as often as Tommy Tuberville says something intelligent.
So what’s up? Beyond the usual suspects driving them away from reading in general (social media, sports, the great outdoors, good bourbon), why do men single out fiction as a genre to avoid?
We fiction fans know the answer already. We know there’s a powerful “truth” in fiction. Often as children, we’ve encountered that “truth” as a shiver of recognition when a character or a situation intersects with our own experience. Pick your own moments. Searching for Lassie or Rin Tin Tin. Escaping the Shrieking Shack with Harry Potter. Discovering the secret room with The Hardy Boys. Meeting Boo Radley with Harper Lee’s Scout.
My first experience with those shivers came at seven when I encountered it in Grace Moon’s The Magic Trail. Without noticing, without trying, I suddenly found myself in lockstep with the Navajo boy Kawani on his journey to find his father. I couldn’t disappear deeply enough into his world. I smelled the mesquite smoke rising from hogans and watched the purple sunsets over the distant mesa and followed him into that magical, vast desert—and, I’ll have you know, in my own leather moccasins I’d begged my parents to buy.
Although I knew I wasn’t really Kawani, thanks to those shivers, I could care about him, share his fears, hope for his future. And so I came to understand empathy, fiction’s unique power.
Empathy is all about connecting, and connecting is all about caring, and it’s this caring stuff that might be what makes fiction a bit too scary for “real” men, men such as Elon Musk, who called empathy in a 2025 podcast as “the fundamental weakness of American civilization.”
Empathy as weakness. Caring as enemy. It’s a chilly reality to contemplate, isn’t it? But a simpler reality, too. Think about it. Less fiction, less empathy. Less empathy, fewer connections. Fewer connections, less concern for consequences.
Elon is not alone. Many men who prefer to live in this fiction-less world consider empathy a disadvantage. And no wonder. It frees them to run their lives (and those around them) with a video-game kind of power. They can start wars on the feeblest of pretexts, mock spiritual leaders, dismiss punitive living costs as a hoax, define immigrants as vermin, deem women unable to control their own bodies.
It is a world I want no part of. I pray we have enough good fiction to get us through it. And that enough real men read it.
D.B. Tipmore, the owner of Selma’s Fair Oaks Books, is the author of My Little Town and Barefoot Boy, a novel to be published by Rattling Good Yarns Press. He can be reached at [email protected]