Replay Sports Cards - Seymour, IN

Replay Sports Cards - Seymour, IN Come visit Indiana's newest sports card shop in Seymour, IN! We're open 7 days a week.

08/05/2026

Replay Gives Back is giving sports cards a second life by donating them to children's hospitals, schools, youth organizations, and community programs—bringing smiles to thousands of kids across the country. ❤️

Our Co-Founder, Brent Schepel, recently joined FOX 32 Chicago to share how this nationwide initiative has grown from a simple idea into something making a real impact.

Together, we're proving that a trading card can be worth far more than what's printed on a price guide.

What a weekend at The ! 🙌 From meeting new collectors to witnessing unforgettable reactions, this year's National remin...
08/05/2026

What a weekend at The ! 🙌

From meeting new collectors to witnessing unforgettable reactions, this year's National reminded us exactly why we love this hobby.

The best part wasn't just the cards—it was the people. Thank you to everyone who stopped by the booth, joined our Trade Nights, shared stories, and made the weekend memorable.

We can't wait to bring that same energy back to Replay Seymour!

Until next year, Chicago! ❤️🏆

08/04/2026

🔥🚨 NATIONAL PICKUPS JUST HIT THE SHOP 🚨🔥

We went to the National Sports Collectors Convention… and we came BACK LOADED. 💥

This is BIG.

We’re talking:

🔥 Modern heat
🔥 Autographs
🔥 Graded slabs
🔥 Rare inserts
🔥 And a TON more bangers

If you’re hunting, investing, or just love the hobby, this drop is for YOU. 🏆

But listen up… 👀
This stuff is NOT going to sit.

The best cards? They’re already getting scooped. Fast. 💨

So don’t wait.

📍 Replay Sports Cards – Seymour, Indiana

Come through THIS WEEK and get first shot before it’s gone. Once it’s gone… it’s gone. 😤

See you in the shop! 🔥

08/03/2026

Founders Box War - an annual Tradition 🥊📦

Mike Martin and Brent Schepel went head-to-head at The National to see who could pull more heat.

🏆 Who won: Mike or Brent?

Thank YOU for the donations so we can do great card drops like this ❤️Every donation made to the Replay Gives Back Found...
07/31/2026

Thank YOU for the donations so we can do great card drops like this ❤️

Every donation made to the Replay Gives Back Foundation helps us share the joy of the hobby with kids who need it most.

We visited La Rabida Children's Hospital in Chicago during The National week and it was filled with smiles, excitement, and unforgettable moments—and none of it would have been possible without the generosity of our amazing customers and community.

07/30/2026

Can White Sox fans pass our test at the ballpark on the eve of The National? 👀⚾

We took to the streets outside the ballpark to put local White Sox fans' knowledge to the test. Get the trivia question right, and you walk away with a FREE White Sox card! 🎉

Some fans made it look easy... others folded under the pressure. 😅⚾

Would you have gotten these right? Drop your score in the comments! ⬇️

⚾ Which MLB stadium should we visit next?

🏙️ The hobby's biggest stage is calling... and Replay Sports Cards is headed to Chicago! 🔥Join us at The National Sports...
07/29/2026

🏙️ The hobby's biggest stage is calling... and Replay Sports Cards is headed to Chicago! 🔥

Join us at The National Sports Collectors Convention as we buy, sell, trade, rip wax, and connect with collectors from around the world!

🎉 Replay Sports Cards will be a sponsor of The Collectors Lounge VIP Trade Night! If you're attending, don't miss some of the biggest nights of the week packed with incredible cards, collectors, and hobby memories.

📍 Find us throughout the show and come check out everything Replay Sports Cards has to offer. We can't wait to see familiar faces and meet new ones!

👇 Who's making the trip to The National this year?

🚨 NOW HIRING – FULL-TIME 🚨📍 Replay Sports Cards – Seymour, IndianaDo you love sports cards? Spend your weekends at card ...
07/29/2026

🚨 NOW HIRING – FULL-TIME 🚨

📍 Replay Sports Cards – Seymour, Indiana

Do you love sports cards? Spend your weekends at card shows? Constantly check eBay comps? Enjoy buying, selling, trading, and talking cards?

If being surrounded by sports cards all day sounds like your dream job, we’d love to talk with you.

We’re looking for someone who:
🏈 Has a genuine passion for sports cards and the hobby
⚾ Enjoys helping customers and building relationships
🏀 Is dependable, motivated, and eager to learn
⚡ Can thrive in a fast-paced retail environment
💬 Loves talking sports, collecting, and all things hobby-related

What we offer:
✅ Full-time position
✅ Competitive pay (negotiable based on experience)
✅ Paid Time Off (PTO)
✅ Retirement plan with company match
✅ Employee discounts
✅ The opportunity to turn your hobby into a career

If you think you’d be a great fit, send your resume and a brief note telling us why you love the hobby to [email protected].

Come join a team that’s passionate about the hobby and helping it grow!

🔥 Replay Trade Night is BACK! 🔥Mark your calendars for Saturday, August 15th and join us from 6PM–9PM (local time) at AL...
07/28/2026

🔥 Replay Trade Night is BACK! 🔥

Mark your calendars for Saturday, August 15th and join us from 6PM–9PM (local time) at ALL Replay Sports Cards locations for an evening packed with buying, selling, trading, ripping, and connecting with fellow collectors! Enjoy FREE giveaway prizes, FREE pizza & drinks, exclusive deals, and plenty of hobby conversations all night long!🤝📦

Whether you're chasing grails, making deals, showing off your latest pickups, or just hanging out with the hobby community, Trade Night is the place to be! Bring your collection, bring your friends, and let's make this our biggest Trade Night yet! 🙌

📍 Saturday, August 15
⏰ 6PM–9PM (Local Time)
🏪 All Replay Sports Cards Locations

Tag a fellow collector down below and let us know which location you'll be attending! 👇

Great weekend for the Replay Seymour crew! 🔥We kicked things off with another incredible July Trade Night filled with gr...
07/28/2026

Great weekend for the Replay Seymour crew! 🔥

We kicked things off with another incredible July Trade Night filled with great deals, awesome conversations, and an amazing community of collectors. But the fun didn't stop there... some of our team laced up their running shoes and tackled a midnight 5K to cap off the night! 🏃💨

As if that wasn't enough, we also had the chance to meet Pittsburgh Steelers RB Jaylen Warren! 🏈

Weekends like these are what Replay is all about—bringing people together, making memories, and having fun both inside and outside the shop. 💙❤️

Let us know your favorite moment of your weekend down in the comments! 👇

Address

1171 W Tipton Street A
Seymour, IN
47274

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 6pm
Tuesday 11am - 6pm
Wednesday 11am - 6pm
Thursday 11am - 6pm
Friday 11am - 8pm
Saturday 11am - 8pm
Sunday 11am - 6pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Replay Sports Cards - Seymour, IN posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category