Sterling Hallmark

Call Directions Website Contact the business

Sterling Hallmark Gifts Collectibles Candy FUN! Located in Stirling New Jersey Sterling Hallmark was opened on June 1, 1969 by Mr. and Mrs. Joseph Allegra.

A Sterling Story

Before opening this Hallmark store in Stirling, they owned a store in Bergen County in 1956 This store was a news store that sold newspapers, candy, and to***co. In 1982 Sterling Hallmark remodeled the store for the first time. Again in 1993 after the passing of Joseph Allegra Sr., his sons, Joseph and Michael, decided to remodel the store. This time, the store was doubled in size from 2,500 square feet to 5,000 square feet; in 1999, the final remodel was completed making the Sterling Store 5,500 square feet. Then on August 1, 2003 the Chatham store was opened.

level up your hostess gift 🍂✨ give her a nora fleming mini, a-nora-ble for fall, but made to be changed out for every se...
10/10/2026

level up your hostess gift 🍂✨ give her a nora fleming mini, a-nora-ble for fall, but made to be changed out for every season. a thoughtful (mini) gift that becomes part of special memories, year after year. 💗


It’s time to let your Christmas spirit shine! Ornament Debut is October 10–18. 🤩 Shop at your nearest Hallmark Gold Crow...
10/09/2026

It’s time to let your Christmas spirit shine! Ornament Debut is October 10–18. 🤩 Shop at your nearest Hallmark Gold Crown store or online to check out all-new ornaments, earn BIG Bonus Points and make some merry memories with your favorite people. See you there! 🥳🎄
Sterling Hallmark of Long Hill Township, NJ

10/09/2026
Thursday, October 8th Squishy Toy stockSquishy toys….. Here today gone tomorrow!
10/08/2026

Thursday, October 8th Squishy Toy stock
Squishy toys….. Here today gone tomorrow!

Look who just arrived in our store! This year’s singing & dancing Snowmen called “Snowball Fight!” ❄️☃️Save $10 when yo...
10/07/2026

Look who just arrived in our store!
This year’s singing & dancing Snowmen called “Snowball Fight!” ❄️☃️

Save $10 when you purchase 3 cards.
Come on in and get yours today! Don’t wait we sold out by November 29 last year!

You’re invited! Join us Oct. 10–18 for Ornament Debut. Shop 150 all-new ornaments as we kick off the most wonderful time...
10/06/2026

You’re invited! Join us Oct. 10–18 for Ornament Debut. Shop 150 all-new ornaments as we kick off the most wonderful time of the year.

Next Saturday is ornament debut!!!Have you turned in your wishlist? You still have time 😉
10/06/2026

Next Saturday is ornament debut!!!
Have you turned in your wishlist? You still have time 😉

Mystery Ornament fun at Ornament Debut!! Be sure to joing us the 10th-18th for 123 new ornaments!
10/05/2026

Mystery Ornament fun at Ornament Debut!! Be sure to joing us the 10th-18th for 123 new ornaments!


One thing about us? We LOVE a little treat! So, of course, we’ll be at Ornament Debut on October 10 picking up a few new...
10/05/2026

One thing about us? We LOVE a little treat! So, of course, we’ll be at Ornament Debut on October 10 picking up a few new favorites. How ‘bout you? 🤩🎄

Keepsake Ornament Debut is just 1 week away! Starts October 10th through October 18th. See over 120 new Hallmark Keepsa...
10/05/2026

Keepsake Ornament Debut is just 1 week away! Starts October 10th through October 18th. See over 120 new Hallmark Keepsake Ornaments.

We are starting today to hang the ornaments on our display panels. Come on by if you want a sneak peek!

Address

1157 Valley Road
Stirling, NJ
07980

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 8pm
Tuesday 9am - 8pm
Wednesday 9am - 8pm
Thursday 9am - 8pm
Friday 9am - 9pm
Saturday 9am - 6pm
Sunday 10am - 5pm

Telephone

+19086471401

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Sterling Hallmark posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Sterling Hallmark:

Shortcuts

Share

Category