The Wrestling Collector

The Wrestling Collector Try one of our Autograph 8X10 Mystery Envelopes Today! Get (12) Hand Signed Photos for Only $60! That’s only $5 per photo!

ORDER HERE: https://thewrestlingcollector.com/store/ols/products/the-mystery-envelope

We will be closing by 3PM today as our ISPW Wrestling will be LOCAL at the Vernon PAL in Vernon, NJ tonight! We will be ...
08/08/2026

We will be closing by 3PM today as our ISPW Wrestling will be LOCAL at the Vernon PAL in Vernon, NJ tonight! We will be bringing a Pop-Up Shop! Come out for a super fun night headlined by some of the best Independent Wrestlers on the PLANET!

08/07/2026

PLEASE NOTE: The Wrestling Collector will be closed today, Friday 8/7.

The Wrestling Collector does birthday parties! 🍅 😜
08/07/2026

The Wrestling Collector does birthday parties! 🍅 😜

08/06/2026

Please Note: We close at 2PM today and will be hosting ISPW Wrestling Pro Wrestling Night at Liberty Science Center! We will have a Pop-Up Shop! Event is from 6-10PM

Who remembers this stuff?!!
08/05/2026

Who remembers this stuff?!!

Who remembers these shirts? 👕
08/05/2026

Who remembers these shirts? 👕

You never know what you are going to find at The Wrestling Collector, New Jersey’s Pro Wrestling Superstore located at t...
08/04/2026

You never know what you are going to find at The Wrestling Collector, New Jersey’s Pro Wrestling Superstore located at the beginning of Sussex County in Stockholm. NJ! Open today until 5PM! Come step back into your childhood today.

The Wrestling Collector
2828 State Route 23
Stockholm, NJ

Happy SummerSlam Sunday! The shop will be open today from Noon-4PM. Kick off your SummerSlam Sunday at The Wrestling Col...
08/02/2026

Happy SummerSlam Sunday! The shop will be open today from Noon-4PM. Kick off your SummerSlam Sunday at The Wrestling Collector, the Pro Wrestling Capital of New Jersey!

💥 Action Figures
💥 Shirts
💥 Autographs
💥 Magazines
💥 Championship Belts
💥 DVD/VHS
💥 Trading cards
💥 Vintage 80s/90s
💥 Pro Wrestling
💥 Birthday Parties
💥 Meet & Greets

We our your one stop shop for everything Professional Wrestling.

💰 We buy your Pro Wrestling merchandise!

⏰ This Weekend’s Hours ⏰
Saturday 11-4PM
Sunday 12-4PM

The Wrestling Collector
2828 State Route 23
Stockholm, NJ 07460
(973) 697-1421

Happy SummerSlam Saturday! The shop will be open today from 11-4PM. Kick off your SummerSlam Weekend at The Wrestling Co...
08/01/2026

Happy SummerSlam Saturday! The shop will be open today from 11-4PM. Kick off your SummerSlam Weekend at The Wrestling Collector, the Pro Wrestling Capital of New Jersey!

💥 Action Figures
💥 Shirts
💥 Autographs
💥 Magazines
💥 Championship Belts
💥 DVD/VHS
💥 Trading cards
💥 Vintage 80s/90s
💥 Pro Wrestling
💥 Birthday Parties
💥 Meet & Greets

We our your one stop shop for everything Professional Wrestling.

💰 We buy your Pro Wrestling merchandise!

⏰ This Weekend’s Hours ⏰
Saturday 11-4PM
Sunday 12-4PM

The Wrestling Collector
2828 State Route 23
Stockholm, NJ 07460
(973) 697-1421

Address

2828 State Route 23
Stockholm, NJ
07460

Opening Hours

Tuesday 11am - 6pm
Wednesday 11am - 6pm
Thursday 11am - 6pm
Friday 11am - 7pm
Saturday 10am - 6pm
Sunday 11am - 4pm

Telephone

+19736971421

Website

,

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Wrestling Collector posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Wrestling Collector:

Shortcuts

Share

Category