Poindexter's Costume & Novelty Shop

Directions Website Contact the business

Poindexter's Costume & Novelty Shop Gifts, Gags & Novelties for every occasion! Costumes & Costume Rentals! Wigs! You can't party without... Poindexter's!

🚨 ONLY TWO SATURDAYS LEFT before HALLOWEEN SATURDAY! 🎃Yep. We said it.Halloween lands on a Saturday this year, and that ...
10/17/2026

🚨 ONLY TWO SATURDAYS LEFT before HALLOWEEN SATURDAY! 🎃

Yep. We said it.

Halloween lands on a Saturday this year, and that means you’ve got TODAY + ONE MORE SATURDAY to get ahead of the last-minute costume scramble. 👀

If you still need a costume, wig, hat, makeup, accessories, or that one ridiculous finishing touch you didn’t know you needed… now is the time to come shop through Poindexter’s.

And remember — there are savings all over the store this season, costumes are moving, and some of our longtime rental pieces are hitting the sales floor too.

Translation: the longer you wait, the more likely somebody else walks out with your costume. 😂

🦇 Batman agrees. Don’t wait for the Bat-Signal.

We’re open today 11–8!

🎃 Shop local — because You Can’t Party without Poindexter’s.
Poindexter's Costume & Novelty Shop

10/15/2026

Your costume isn’t finished until the face is. 👀🎨

Robert’s taking you behind the makeup counter today — and if you haven’t looked through Poindexter’s theatrical makeup selection yet, you might be surprised by how much is hiding.

We’ve got cream makeup, water-activated makeup, blood gels, blood paste, liquid blood, special-effects products and plenty more to help take your Halloween look from “I have a costume” to “oh okay… WOW, that’s good.” 😂

Whether you’re going creepy, bloody, glamorous, theatrical, completely over-the-top — or just wonderfully weird — come in and let us help you find what you need.

And yes… there are makeup deals to be found too. 👀💸

Watch Robert’s rundown, then come in and see for yourself. There’s a lot more back there than people realize. 🎭

🎃 Shop local —
Because you can’t party without Poindexter’s

Poindexter's Costume & Novelty Shop

10/08/2026

Halloween savings are officially happening at Poindexter’s! 🎃💸

Robert’s giving you the rundown on how our costume discounts are working this season — and yes, we really did go through every costume in the store to get them marked and ready.

Adult costumes are discounted 20%, 30%, 40% or 50% OFF depending on the color tab, and kids’ costumes are 40% OFF!

So if you’ve been waiting to figure out your costume… now is the time to come shop while the selection is still good. 👀

Watch the video for the full breakdown — including Robert’s very important message 😂

Shop local — because you can’t party without Poindexter’s. 🎭🎃

Poindexter's Costume & Novelty Shop

10/07/2026

Not everything has to be scary on Halloween. ✨

Sometimes you can be grand, dramatic, regal… and beautiful.

We’re starting to bring some of our higher-end rental costumes out of the rental collection and onto the sales floor for purchase — including these gorgeous Renaissance-inspired gowns.

These are detailed, theatrical pieces we’ve held onto for years, and now they’re becoming available to own.

Perfect for Halloween, Renaissance events, theater, themed parties, photoshoots… or just because you’ve always wanted an excuse to dress like royalty. 👑

More pieces are hitting the floor as we go, and once they’re gone, they’re gone.

Come see what treasures are coming out of the Poindexter’s rental collection. 🎭✨

We are “Roaring” into this Halloween season with tons of sales! Come on by and check us out with our extended hours 11-8...
10/05/2026

We are “Roaring” into this Halloween season with tons of sales! Come on by and check us out with our extended hours 11-8 now Monday thru Saturday. Plenty of time to shimmy your way on down and get some awesome stuff for this season! So come on by, say hi to Toby, and get your Halloween on! Also remember you can’t Party without Poindexter’s!

This weather may not have you feeling spooky but we can sure fix that. It’s October and Poindexter’s is open on Sunday n...
10/04/2026

This weather may not have you feeling spooky but we can sure fix that. It’s October and Poindexter’s is open on Sunday now for the month! 12 to 5 we are here ready to help you with your scares and treats, we have a ton of awesome costumes all on sale ranging from 20%, 30%, 40%, and 50% off! Come stop by and let us help you make this Halloween Spooktacular! Also remember you can’t party without Poindexter’s!

Trying to save a little money this Halloween? 💵🎃We may not be able to turn you into a real $100 bill… but we CAN help yo...
10/01/2026

Trying to save a little money this Halloween? 💵🎃

We may not be able to turn you into a real $100 bill… but we CAN help you save while you shop. 😂

And if you haven’t figured out your costume yet… now’s the time! Don’t wait until the last minute and be late to the party. 👻 We’ve got wigs, masks, makeup, accessories, and costumes to help you pull the whole look together.

🚨 🎃 New Seasonal Halloween Hours:
Sunday: 12 PM – 5 PM
Monday – Saturday: 11 AM – 8 PM 🚨

Come have some Halloween fun with us and help celebrate our 28th Halloween season at Poindexter’s. 🧡

See you soon, Twin Falls! 👻 Poindexter's Costume & Novelty Shop

Robin Toby (also Maid Marian 😆) is here to give you the all the deals and steals at Poindexter’s! Tons of sales store wi...
09/29/2026

Robin Toby (also Maid Marian 😆) is here to give you the all the deals and steals at Poindexter’s! Tons of sales store wide and costumes ranging from 20%, 30%, 40%, and 50% off! Also 40% off all kids costumes! Perfect time to come on in and grab some costumes for fun all year long! Remember you can’t Party without Poindexter’s!

I bet you didn’t know Poindexter’s had THIS much theatrical makeup. 👀🎭Face paint, character makeup, prosthetics, horns, ...
09/28/2026

I bet you didn’t know Poindexter’s had THIS much theatrical makeup. 👀🎭

Face paint, character makeup, prosthetics, horns, ears, wounds, burns, fake blood, special-effects pieces and all those little details that can take a costume from “I threw something together” to okayyyy… NOW THAT’S IMPRESSIVE. 🤩

Whether you’re putting together a Halloween look, theater costume, character, monster or something completely weird — there’s a whole lot more hiding in this section than you might expect.

And remember Robert…This is one of his specialties. If you’re not sure what you need or how to pull a look together, ask him!

You’ll also spot quite a few retirement-sale tags throughout the section right now. 👀

Come browse while the selection is still good!

🎃 Poindexter's Costume & Novelty Shop

09/24/2026

Stop by today 4:30-5:30!!!

Address

257 Main Avenue W
Twin Falls, ID
83301

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 8pm
Tuesday 11am - 8pm
Wednesday 11am - 8pm
Thursday 11am - 8pm
Friday 11am - 8pm
Saturday 11am - 8pm
Sunday 12pm - 5pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Poindexter's Costume & Novelty Shop posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Poindexter's Costume & Novelty Shop:

Shortcuts

Share

Category