Bethany’s Cookie Jar

07/29/2026

Happy birthday, Bailey!

07/27/2026

Lennon knew exactly what she wanted: pink, pink, and more pink! Happy 4th birthday, Lennon! 👑

07/26/2026

This 70th birthday set was a whole V I B E ✌🏻🍄🪩

07/25/2026

Last toast on the coast!! 🐚💍

07/22/2026

Checked into my 30s 🪩✌🏻

07/15/2026

Conner just can’t wait TWO be king 👑 🦁

07/13/2026

Welcome to Mattie Jo National Park 🌲

07/12/2026

After taking the month of June off, I dove in head first with this “Sea You Soon” baby shower set!! 🌊⚓️🐙

07/10/2026

Ever wonder why sugar cookies cost so much? Let's talk about it 👇🏻👇🏻👇🏻

Sugar cookies take way more work than most people realize. Here's an estimated time breakdown for the two-dozen order pictured below:
- Make dough (1 hr)
- Roll, cut, and bake (2 hrs)
- Make icing (30 min)
- Design and print cutters (4 hrs)
- Mix colors and consistencies (2–3 hrs)
- Base flood all cookies (4–5 hrs)
- Prep and upload custom graphics for Eddie the Edible Printer (matching print size and color) (3 hrs)
- Fine detail work (4–5 hrs)
- Clean up (1 hr)
- Individually package cookies (1 hr)

Total: 22.5–25.5 hours for two dozen cookies.

My starting price is $65/dozen (so $130 total in this scenario)

That works out to $5.78–$5.10/hour, and that's before factoring in the cost of ingredients, packaging materials, or electricity.

Even on orders where I already have the cutters and dough made (just not baked), it still takes 17–20 hours…which only brings me to $7.65–$6.50/hour.

If you’ve made it this far, thank you for coming to my Ted Talk. I absolutely enjoy making cookies. The Lord has blessed me with this talent, and I am TRULY thankful for every single order that I receive. I do NOT take it lightly that my customers spend their hard-earned money on cookies from me. BUT… it would be truly unfair to myself if I only charged $25-$30 per dozen.

06/30/2026

God bless the USA!!

Thank you Bethany Terrell Rebbe , for sponsoring a flag in our Flags Across The Wood Yard display. 🇺🇸

We’re honored to celebrate America’s 250th Birthday of Freedom with our community.