But I wish it was black

But I wish it was black But I Wish It Was Black ®
curated secondhand
dark clothing, home decor + accessories
for those who prefer it black
⬇️ online + in person

09/08/2026

Some would say it’s a dream come true.
📍Wethersfield CT

09/08/2026

“Darling, I always wear black”

IFYKYK

But I Wish It Was Black is a curated secondhand boutique specializing in dark clothing, home decor, and accessories — selected with intention for those who prefer it black.

Check us out at Mill Street Marketplace in Wethersfield CT

09/08/2026

And these gorgeous brass and crystal pieces are now available in my shop at Mill Street Marketplace

Fair warning, they are a much higher price point then the pieces I usually have but I am expanding the Items I offer and these were way too special to leave behind.

What are your favorite black pieces to buy?!
09/04/2026

What are your favorite black pieces to buy?!

09/02/2026

Restock time for the lovers of black!

Check it out at Mill Street Marketplace in Wethersfield CT

Or shop online on my website

09/01/2026

New series of frequently asked questions about my all black secondhand shop!

Be sure to follow Mill Street Marketplace

Welcome to the secondhand shop made just for the lovers of black.Visit in person at Mill Street Marketplace Shop online!...
08/31/2026

Welcome to the secondhand shop made just for the lovers of black.

Visit in person at Mill Street Marketplace
Shop online!

See you on Saturday Sept 19th at Bats and Black Cats Fair !!!This event is going to be so good, make sure you check it o...
08/29/2026

See you on Saturday Sept 19th at Bats and Black Cats Fair !!!
This event is going to be so good, make sure you check it out and if you want to shop BIWIWB come visit on Saturday.

05/19/2026

If you live in Connecticut and love to wear black, be sure to check out But I wish it was black!
Located inside Street Marketplace in Wethersfield CT

I hit 4K followers! And to show my appreciation, I want to curate a style bundle just for you!What you will win: A curat...
05/18/2026

I hit 4K followers! And to show my appreciation, I want to curate a style bundle just for you!

What you will win:
A curated style bundle that will include clothing and accessories (4-6 pieces total, $135 value)

Once the winner is announced I will reach out to discuss your personal style to curate something you will love!

Shipping will be covered by me, US ONLY.

How to enter:
1. Follow and like this post.
2. Tag 2 black loving besties in the comments.
3. Share this post to your story!

Super easy!

This giveaway will close on weds at 8pm (5/20/26) winner will be announced Thursday 5/21!

Address

36 Mill Street
Wethersfield, CT
06109

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when But I wish it was black posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to But I wish it was black:

Shortcuts

Share

Category