South Side Toys and More

South Side Toys and More BUY, SELL, TRADE! We are a family owned toy store that sells new toys, vintage toys, Magic: the Gathering, custom action figures, comics, and so much more.

We BUY, SELL, TRADE: Comic Books, Toys, Video Games, Marvel, DC, NECA, Horror, Transformers, MOTU, Voltron, Hot Toys, Funko, Pokemon, Trading Cards, GI Joe, Star Wars, TMNT, and more! We also have gaming space available for Friday Night Magic, D&D, Pokemon, etc. Oh, and do you have any toys you are looking to get rid of?! South Side Toys & More wants to buy them from you (cash or in store credit).

We are looking to trade toys for cards! Sports Pokemon or ??? We still have a lot of product since the store close and a...
05/03/2026

We are looking to trade toys for cards! Sports Pokemon or ??? We still have a lot of product since the store close and are selling online.

We are looking to downsize. So take our big stuff for your cards. Email or message us here. We can meet at our storage units or let us know what you like from our eBay page.

We have closed the store front. With rising rent and declining sales we simply couldn’t continue to keep the store open....
05/13/2025

We have closed the store front. With rising rent and declining sales we simply couldn’t continue to keep the store open. We are still selling on eBay and exit 76 antique mall.

We are still buying. If you have any questions or something to sell please let us know!

03/22/2025

We are running a bit behind today. We will be open a little late today .

Can you hear it brother, that’s right new wrestlers just in. Stop by Thursday, Friday, or Saturday and pick one up. Whh...
03/19/2025

Can you hear it brother, that’s right new wrestlers just in. Stop by Thursday, Friday, or Saturday and pick one up. Whhhhhhooooooo, Oh Yeah

This just in… Every Friday in March we will have a 20% off store wide sale. So come on in and get your collecting on.
03/12/2025

This just in… Every Friday in March we will have a 20% off store wide sale. So come on in and get your collecting on.

Awesome new figures just in.
02/26/2025

Awesome new figures just in.

New stock in the store!
02/25/2025

New stock in the store!

Nice vehicles and play sets. Good news nice boxes. Bad news most are incomplete.
02/14/2025

Nice vehicles and play sets. Good news nice boxes. Bad news most are incomplete.

New cool stuff just in
02/05/2025

New cool stuff just in

02/01/2025

New stuff new look!

Address

Whiteland, IN

Opening Hours

Thursday 11am - 6pm
Friday 11am - 6pm
Saturday 11am - 6pm

Telephone

+13178640723

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when South Side Toys and More posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to South Side Toys and More:

Shortcuts

Share

Category