The Old Trail Variety Store

09/26/2026

Good Saturday morning, 9/26/26.
Nice selection of mums delivered late last evening for you to choose from today - $6 each pot. They are on the tables and lot more inside gate.

Pumpkins are everywhere $1 and up. They are in bins out front, on racks, inside gate on skids, (tiny pumpkins and gourds on wagon are 2 for $1). Create your own stackers and have fun picking pumpkins with your family and friends.
Take some pictures with the "scary new guy in town" at the corner of building out front.

SOURDOUGH FLAVORS TODAY:
Sundried tomatoes and basil
Everything bagel
Cranberry orange
Smore's
Classic
(Locally made by Heather)

Added more fresh local produce last evening:

Red seedless watermelons, broccoli, large cabbage, jalapeño peppers, sweet frying peppers, serano peppers, cherry tomatoes, green bell peppers, and more.

BULK TOMATOES - $10 - 1/2 BUSHEL

Inside, check out the fun fall decorations for yourself and the kiddos - $ .50 and up. We are restocking daily. Shop with us first and save money. See you soon OPEN Thursday 12noon-8pm, Friday, Saturday and Sunday 9am-5pm.
CASH ONLY- 717-938-6426

2555 Old Trail Road, York Haven, PA
717-938-6426
See you soon,

09/25/2026

Good Friday morning, 9/25/26.
Another beautiful fall day. We open at 9, lots of fall decorations inside as well as some mums and lots of sizes and types of pumpkins and gourds outside - out front on racks, on wagon, in bins and inside gate.

SOURDOUGH BREAD FLAVORS TODAY:
(they are all delicious)
Sundried tomato and basil
Smore's
Everything bagel
Cranberry orange
Classic

BULK TOMATOES $10 - 1/2 BUSHEL

Amish baked goods, brown eggs, local smoked cheese and lots of produce in our coolers.

Enjoy your day, hope to see you soon
2555 Old Trail Road, York Haven, PA
CASH ONLY - 717-938-6426

09/24/2026

What a beautiful fall Thursday 9/24/26.

PRODUCE in coolers today:
blueberries, strawberries, navel oranges, pineapples, pears, yellow seedless watermelons, broccoli, cabbage, sweet frying peppers, bell peppers, romaine lettuce, red beets, cucumbers, zucchini, butternut squash, delicata squash, cherry tomatoes, sweet potatoes and more. See pictures for more info.

AMISH BAKED GOODS are waiting for you to enjoy - fruit and crème pies, flavored sweet breads, apple dumplings, angel food cake, rasberry cheesecake, banana rolls, pumpkin rolls and 12 flavors of whoopie pies.

BULK ITEMS TODAY:
Tomatoes $10 - 1/2 bushel
Pears $12 - 1/2 bushel
Eva potatoes - $10 - 20 lb. bag

SOURDOUGH BREAD flavors today -
Cranberry Orange, Everything Bagel,
Smore's, Classic

OUTSIDE - SEASONAL ITEMS:
Nice selection of mums, pumpkins, gourds, Indian corn and more.

INSIDE - fall decorations are coming in daily to help you create your own ideas for your home. Fun stuff for the kiddos too. Save money, shop with us first.
You may be pleasantly surprised at our prices and save some gas - one stop for a lot of items on your shopping list.

Hope to see you soon, enjoy your day.
2555 Old Trail Road, York Haven, PA
Open Thursday by 12noon-8pm, Friday, Saturday and Sunday 9am-5pm.
717-938-6426, CASH ONLY

09/24/2026

09/20/2026

Good Sunday morning, 9/20/26.
Kinda dreary rainy morning, but we are open today 9am-5pm, if you are out and about. You never know what you might find. We have produce, few Amish pies, SMOKED CHEESE, brown eggs, duck eggs, snacks, local FLAVORED SOURDOUGH BREAD and the classic sourdough bread as well.
Yellow seedless watermelons inside, red seedless watermelons outside.

Lots of fall and spooky decorations to choose from, adding daily to our shelves.

OUTSIDE, we have mums, asters, celosia, lots of pumpkins and gourds.
Some shrubbery inside gate too

2555 Old Trail Road, York Haven PA
717-938-6426, CASH ONLY

09/19/2026

Good Saturday morning, 9/19/26.
We have FRESH BICOLOR CORN, $4 a dozen. Coolers have more fruits and veggies for you to enjoy and outside we have red seedless watermelons $3 each, YELLOW seedless watermelons $5 ea.

We have fresh local SOURDOUGH BREAD, (6 flavors), Amish baked fruit and crème pies, whoopie pies, local SMOKED cheese, brown eggs and duck eggs. (Look at pictures for more info.)

BULK ITEMS - 1/2 bushel:
Pears - $12
Apples - $16
Tomatoes - $15

If you are ready to do some fall decorating, we have asters, mums, celosia, and kale. Lots and lots of pumpkins ($1 and up), gourds and bundles of Indian corn. Pumpkins and gourds are on the wagon, racks and more inside gate.

Lots of fall and spooky fun decorations are added daily inside the store. Stop in, see how we can help you save money.
Open Thursday 12noon-8pm, Friday, Saturday and Sunday 9am-5pm.

2555 Old Trail Road, York Haven, PA 717-938-6426, CASH ONLY

09/18/2026

BICOLOR CORN IS HERE
$4 DOZEN

Don't forget to grab more produce inside, homemade fresh Sourdough bread, brown eggs, SMOKED CHEESE or some Amish baked goods.

Lots of pumpkins and mums to choose from too.

2555 Old Trail Road, York Haven, PA - CASH ONLY - 717-938-6426
OPEN Thursday 12noon-8pm, Friday, Saturday and Sunday 9am-5pm.

09/18/2026

Good Friday morning, 9/18/26.
Last evening we got a delivery of
"Fresh Sourdough Bread" for you.
We have lots of flavors for you to enjoy, added a few new ones today:

Blueberries & cream (cream cheese)
Triple cheddar
Pumpkin spice
Jalapeño cheddar
Rosemary & olive oil
Classic
Italian

Ready to start decorating for fall?
Shop with us first and save money.
We have lots of mums, pumpkins, gourds, Indian corn and spooky decorations inside for you.

If you get hungry while you are decorating, we have lots of healthy produce and sweet Amish homemade baked goods inside. Bulk tomatoes, apples and pears inside too.

Thank you for supporting local and we appreciate all our customers.
See you soon, enjoy your day.
2555 Old Trail Road, York Haven, PA
CASH ONLY - 717-938-6426

09/17/2026

Good sunny Thursday morning, 9/17/26.

All our coolers are BULGING with fresh local produce, including more bicolor corn for you today. AMISH baked fruit pies, crème pies, pumpkin rolls, banana rolls, flavored sweet breads, apple dumplings, angel food cake, rasberry cheesecake, carrot or chocolate cake, molasses or chocolate chip cookies, 12 flavors of whoopie pies and more. Brown eggs, duck eggs and 10 types of local SMOKED cheese. See pictures for more details.

FRESH SOURDOUGH BREAD FLAVORS:
Pumpkin spice, Rosemary/olive oil,
Jalapeño cheddar, Italian, Classic
(this is locally made by Heather)

BULK ITEMS - 1/2 bushel box
Tomatoes - $15
Apples - $16
(Evercrisp, Gala, Crunch-A-Bunch)
Shenandoah pears - $12

OUTISIDE:
Red watermelons $5 each
Lots of mums -
hanging baskets, planters, pots
Ornamental peppers
Flowering kale
Neck pumpkins
Gourds and all types of pumpkins
Indian corn - bunches

Lots of choices, hope to see you soon. Thank you for shopping local, we appreciate all our customers.
Enjoy your day.
Open Thursday by 12noon-8pm, Friday, Saturday and Sunday 9am-5pm.
2555 Old Trail Road, York Haven, PA CASH ONLY - 717-938-6426