One More Time

One More Time The One More Time stores are Columbus' premiere consignment & resale shops which offer clothing, accessories, furniture and home decor.

Our low prices on high quality merchandise make one more time stores a popular destination for shoppers! We make it easy to part with your less-loved clothes and accessories and turn them into cash. And once you clear out your closets, we can help you fill it back up with great new-to-you items at low prices. one more time provides two ways for you to sell your clothes. We can either buy your item

s outright or place them on consignment. Please browse our website for information and then feel free to give us a call or come visit us. Come on in and browse our wide selection of high quality merchandise priced at a fraction of the original cost.

🍂✨ Item of the Day! ✨🍂 Make a statement in this gorgeous Desigual coat! 🧥💫 Women’s Size Large, $96.99Perfect for adding ...
09/10/2026

🍂✨ Item of the Day! ✨🍂 Make a statement in this gorgeous Desigual coat! 🧥💫 Women’s Size Large, $96.99

Perfect for adding a little style to your fall layers while keeping cozy on those crisp days! 🍁🤎

Stop by One More Time and give it a try before it finds its next home! 🛍️

09/10/2026

👜 Bag lovers, this one’s for you! Join Chris tomorrow at 3 PM for her live bag show! You never know what treasure might make an appearance.

Set your reminder and see you there! 👀👜

Fall layering season is coming in hot 🍂Today’s men’s new arrivals are all about those easy-to-layer tops you’ll want in ...
09/09/2026

Fall layering season is coming in hot 🍂

Today’s men’s new arrivals are all about those easy-to-layer tops you’ll want in your rotation this fall. Perfect for throwing on over a tee or wearing on their own when the temps start to drop. 🙌

Which one would you wear? 👀 Let us know below!

Shop all of today’s new arrivals in store or online!

It’s not wrong to pick all 3 🤭 Shop our in store displays Tuesdays through Saturdays from 10-6 ⏰ We’ll be here and we’re...
09/09/2026

It’s not wrong to pick all 3 🤭 Shop our in store displays Tuesdays through Saturdays from 10-6 ⏰ We’ll be here and we’re happy to help! 🛒

Truly a treasure 🥹✨‼️ The perfect statement bag is waiting for you at One More Time, online and in store 🍁 🏷️ $75.99 | M...
09/09/2026

Truly a treasure 🥹✨
‼️ The perfect statement bag is waiting for you at One More Time, online and in store 🍁

🏷️ $75.99 | Maurizio Taiuti 👜

09/09/2026

🍂 Fall is filling the racks! We are accepting Fall consignments and loving all the new seasonal pieces coming through the door. If you have Fall favorites sitting in your closet, bring them our way!!! 🛍️✨

09/08/2026
Which side are you shopping? ⬅️➡️Fall menswear is officially in store🍂Cleaning out your closet? Bring your men’s fall cl...
09/08/2026

Which side are you shopping? ⬅️➡️

Fall menswear is officially in store🍂
Cleaning out your closet? Bring your men’s fall clothing and accessories to One More Time, no appointment necessary!

✔️ Bring items in neatly folded or on hangers
✔️ We’ll review everything while you shop
✔️ Receive an offer the same day

Choose the option that works best for you:

• Consignment (50/50 profit split between you and One More Time)
• Store Credit (use your earnings toward purchases in-store)
• Buyout (receive cash for accepted items)

📍 Columbus, OH
🕙 Tuesday–Saturday | 10 AM–6 PM
💻 onemoretime.com

Address

1521 W 5th Avenue
Columbus, OH
43212

Opening Hours

Tuesday 11am - 6pm
Wednesday 11am - 6pm
Thursday 11am - 6pm
Friday 11am - 6pm
Saturday 11am - 6pm

Telephone

+16144860031

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when One More Time posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to One More Time:

Shortcuts

Share

Category