What are the opening hours?

Tuesday 11am - 6pm Wednesday 11am - 6pm Thursday 11am - 6pm Friday 11am - 6pm Saturday 11am - 6pm

One More Time

Call Directions Website Contact the business

The One More Time stores are Columbus' premiere consignment & resale shops which offer clothing, accessories, furniture and home decor.

Our low prices on high quality merchandise make one more time stores a popular destination for shoppers! We make it easy to part with your less-loved clothes and accessories and turn them into cash. And once you clear out your closets, we can help you fill it back up with great new-to-you items at low prices. one more time provides two ways for you to sell your clothes. We can either buy your items outright or place them on consignment. Please browse our website for information and then feel free to give us a call or come visit us. Come on in and browse our wide selection of high quality merchandise priced at a fraction of the original cost.

10/28/2026

The finishing touches make all the difference! 🧢🧤

Today’s men’s new arrivals are all about the accessories! We’ve got three hats and two pairs of leather gloves ready to level up your fall and winter wardrobe 🍂

Which would you grab first? Let us know below! 👇

Shop in store or online today!

10/28/2026

Flower child meets cowboy boots?? ✨
These Ariat boots are blooming with personality! Featuring colorful wildflower embroidery, a tan finish and a square toe, they’re a fun find for any boot lover out there. 👢

📏 Youth Size 4.5 (approximately a women’s size 6)
🏷️ $29.99
📍 Available in store only at One More Time on W. 5th Ave. in Columbus! Come try them on today 🌺🌸

10/28/2026

What do you need for game day? 🏈
Hats, bags, hoodies, cardigans, tees, sweaters, jackets??

We’ve got a little bit of everything to help you show up in your favorite team colors… Scarlet and Gray, of course! 😉❤️🩶

Stop by One More Time and see what Buckeye treasures you can find 👀

10/28/2026

Your fall wardrobe called… it wants a little refresh! 😉🍂 Come browse the racks and see what’s new! 👀⬇️
And if your closet is ready for a refresh, we are still accepting Fall & Winter consignments no appointment needed!

10/27/2026

Still working on your Halloween costume? We’ve got you covered! 🕸️ Chris showed off pieces from the store that are perfect for creating a costume, adding those finishing touches, or putting together a last-minute Halloween look. 🧙‍♀️🖤

Why buy a costume you’ll only wear once when you can get creative with secondhand finds? 😉♻️

Catch the full live replay anytime on our Facebook or YouTube, and stop by to see what costume-worthy treasures you can find!

10/27/2026

We’re soaking up every bit of this perfect fall weather! 🍁☀️ The layers, the leaves, the cozy outfits… fall really knows how to show off 😆 Stop by One More Time and shop our latest fall finds… you never know what treasure is waiting for you!

10/27/2026

Oh, Treasure Hunters 🗣️
Check out these Michael Kors tennis shoes! 👟

Perfect for fall, perfect for adding a little sparkle to a casual outfit and even better at this price!

Add them to your cart today and make these beauties yours 🛒

10/24/2026

Some outfit inspo from our men’s section 📸
Like the look? Come snag it at One More Time! 🧢🧥👕👖
Scroll for the details 👉

10/24/2026

A subject we could go on & on about 👜
Come find your next favorite bag at One More Time! ✨

Address

1521 W 5th Avenue
Columbus, OH
43212

Opening Hours

Tuesday	11am - 6pm
Wednesday	11am - 6pm
Thursday	11am - 6pm
Friday	11am - 6pm
Saturday	11am - 6pm

Telephone

+16144860031

Website

http://onemoretime.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when One More Time posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.