Indy Card Exchange

Call Directions Website Contact the business

Indy Card Exchange Welcome to Indy Card Exchange! We are your one stop, full-service local card shop serving Central Indiana and beyond.
(235)

11/05/2026

Topps Flagship is here! Oh, and a slightly big announcement!

11/05/2026

The winners of our Halloween Costume Contest! Bring this post in and show the front counter to claim your prize.

Thanks to all participants and thank you making it a fun event!

11/04/2026

Golden Mirror on the wall, who’s the goldest of them all?

Famed is the greatness, Tyrese Haliburton, whose vision is unmatched and brilliance shines bright. And mighty Pascal Siakam, whose strength and grace command the court with royal might. But wait! A golden prince Braden Smith, I now behold, whose wisdom and wizardry are worth more than gold! Three kings of the court, each noble and true, for none is more golden than these chosen few!

Look for your Indiana Pacers Golden Mirror Variation images in the new Topps Basketball release, starting tomorrow, Thursday, November 5th!

Our framer just informed us that they are guaranteeing framing returns by Thanksgiving for anything dropped off by this ...
11/04/2026

Our framer just informed us that they are guaranteeing framing returns by Thanksgiving for anything dropped off by this coming Sunday, November 8th, by 5pm EST!

Indy Card Exchange Weekly Newsletter: 11/3/2026 - 11/9/2026 -
11/03/2026

Indy Card Exchange Weekly Newsletter: 11/3/2026 - 11/9/2026 -

Upcoming events and pre-orders for this week's releases inside!

This months register roundup donation charity is the Marine Corps Reserve Toys for Tots!For every cent that you donate, ...
11/02/2026

This months register roundup donation charity is the Marine Corps Reserve Toys for Tots!

For every cent that you donate, we are matching it! Let’s make some kids Christmas something to remember!

https://secure.toysfortots.org/a/donatetoday

The month of September and October, our exchangers helped raise $1219.45 for local flood victims!! Thank you all so much for your generosity

The year has flown by! One of our favorite days in the shop is on its way; Black Friday!There will be door busters, sale...
11/02/2026

The year has flown by! One of our favorite days in the shop is on its way; Black Friday!

There will be door busters, sales on wax and memorabilia, hourly giveaways, and a grand prize raffle!

More information dropping each week!

It's Halloween time at Indy Card Exchange! Any kid who wears their costume to the shop Friday through Sunday will receiv...
10/29/2026

It's Halloween time at Indy Card Exchange! Any kid who wears their costume to the shop Friday through Sunday will receive some FREE packs! Plus, we will award store credit for the top 3 costumes! Happy Halloween 🎃👻

10/27/2026

Pack wars with Camryn Bynum and Blue

10/27/2026

For all of Blue hard work on the pricing challenge, we had a surprise!

Address

7035 East 96th Street, Suite P
Indianapolis, IN
46250

Opening Hours

Tuesday 11am - 6pm
Wednesday 11am - 6pm
Thursday 11am - 6pm
Friday 11am - 6pm
Saturday 11am - 5pm
Sunday 12pm - 5pm

Telephone

+13172548681

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Indy Card Exchange posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Indy Card Exchange:

Shortcuts

Share

Nearby shops